BP Deepwater Horizon: the spill, the court cases and the recovery claims
- Between 4,900 and 7,600 of my large juvenile and adult sea turtles were killed, and between 56,000 and 166,000 small juveniles, according to the Trustees. Nearly 35,000 hatchlings were injured by the response itself. Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees
- In my waters, 2 to 5 trillion larval fish were affected, according to the Trustees. Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees
- My Barataria Bay bottlenose dolphins: the Trustees found 35% more deaths, 46% more failed reproduction and 37% more adverse health effects than in a healthy population, and estimated up to a 51% decrease in the population. Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees
- NOAA's June 2024 assessment gives a maximum reduction of 45% for those dolphins and 35 years to recover to 95% of baseline. It reports reproductive success of 0.185, which it describes as less than one in five detected pregnancies producing a viable calf, says disease conditions have persisted and worsened, and gives an abundance of 2,071 in the 2019 survey. NOAA Fisheries
- The Marine Mammal Commission analysis gives a 51% mean decline for the stock and about 32 years to recover under its refined model. Marine Mammal Commission
- A model coordinated by NOAA projected that my Barataria Bay dolphin population would halve within ten years and take 40 years to recover. University of St Andrews
- Seven years after the spill my deep-sea coral colonies had not recovered; recovery was estimated at up to 30 years in a study of 326 colonies. Gulf of Mexico Research Initiative
- Sperm whales declined by up to 7%; 48% of Bryde's whales were affected, with a decline of up to 22%. Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees
- No Trustee document from 2024 to 2026 describes any injured resource of mine as restored or recovered. Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees
- About 3.19 million barrels of oil entered my waters.US District Court finding (2015), after about 810,000 barrels collected
- At least 2,100 km of my coastline were oiled.At least 1,300 miles, eastern Texas to the Florida Panhandle
- Up to 84,500 of my birds died.Trustee range 51,600–84,500 (2016); a USGS report (2026) gives 56,141–102,399
- 11 people died.
- 17 people were injured.
- Company or project BP: Its 16 March 2015 report said the Gulf had returned to baseline, fish populations were sound and heavily oiled marsh shoreline had fallen from 86 to 0.7 miles.
- Government and regulators NOAA: Said the same day that BP had misinterpreted and misapplied the data and that effects would most likely last for generations.
- Government and regulators Head of Louisiana's coastal protection agency: Said BP had used the data selectively.
- Government and regulators Deepwater Horizon Trustees (2016): Up to a 51% decrease; about 39 years to recover without restoration. Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees
- Researchers Marine Mammal Commission analysis: 51% mean decline; about 32 years to recover under the refined model. Marine Mammal Commission
- Government and regulators NOAA stock assessment (June 2024): 45% maximum reduction; 35 years to recover to 95% of baseline. NOAA Fisheries
An offshore rig drilling BP's Macondo exploration well exploded in the Gulf of Mexico on 20 April 2010, killing 11 workers; oil flowed for 87 days. BP pleaded guilty in a criminal case that carried $4 billion in payments and signed a $20.8 billion civil settlement paid until 2031; by the end of 2025, $2.44 billion of up to $8.8 billion set aside for natural resources had been spent.
Spent by the Trustees to end-2025, against BP's cumulative pre-tax charge to end-2018. Different windows; not a ratio. See Who gained.
Status As of October 2026: BP's settlement installments run to 2031, the Trustees had spent $2.44bn of up to $8.8bn by end-2025, no Trustee document from 2024-2026 declares an injured resource restored, and the Trustees' next programmatic review is expected in late 2026.
- BP — Recorded a $11.857bn tax credit on spill costs in 2010. BP p.l.c. (SEC filing)
- BP — From 2011 to 2025 its profit attributable to shareholders totalled $75.4bn, and its Gulf of Mexico production was worth about $108bn gross (estimate, not profit). BP p.l.c. (SEC filing)
- BP shareholders — $56.2bn in dividends and share buybacks in 2021–2025 (estimate, cash-flow basis); dividends were suspended in 2010 for eight months. BP p.l.c. (SEC filing)
- Transocean — Received $560m from hull insurers for the rig and recorded a $267m gain on the loss; BP later paid it $125m for legal fees. Transocean (SEC filing)
- Anadarko — Recognised a $163m gain for insurance recoveries in 2011. Anadarko (SEC filing)
- BP — A cumulative pre-tax charge of $67.0bn by the end of 2018, including $4bn in criminal fines and penalties and the $20.8bn settlement; it recovered $4bn from Anadarko, $1.065bn from MOEX and $250m from Cameron. BP p.l.c. (SEC filing)
- Transocean — $400m criminal fine and $1bn civil penalty, plus $211.75m to two plaintiff classes, paid from cash. US Department of Justice
- Halliburton — $1.1bn class settlement; of about $1.5bn in settlement and legal costs, $403m was reimbursed by insurers and Chubb Bermuda refused about $200m. Halliburton (SEC filing)
- Anadarko — $159.5m Clean Water Act penalty and $4bn paid to BP. NBC News
- Gulf businesses, fishers and residents — Federal fishery closures peaked at 88,522 square miles, about 37% of Gulf federal waters; the Gulf Coast Claims Facility paid at least $6.2bn to more than 220,000 claimants. US Department of Justice
- Clean-up workers and coastal residents (medical class) — About 37,000 claims were filed and about 78% were initially rejected; 40 of about 23,000 approved claimants received the top award of $60,700. Fortune
- US taxpayers — US PIRG estimated $15.3bn of the $20.8bn settlement could be deducted, a tax benefit of about $5.35bn (advocacy-group estimate; the actual deduction is undisclosed). Accounting Today
- 11 workers killed, 17 injured — In the explosion and fire on 20 April 2010. Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees
- Birds — 51,600 to 84,500 birds of at least 93 species died, plus 4,600 to 17,900 chicks (Trustee estimate). Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees
- Sea turtles — 4,900 to 7,600 large juvenile and adult sea turtles killed (Trustee estimate). Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees
- Fish and shellfish — 2 to 5 trillion larval fish killed and 4 to 8.3 billion oysters lost (Trustee estimates). Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees
- Barataria Bay bottlenose dolphins — Up to a 45% population reduction and 35 years to recover (NOAA, 2024). NOAA Fisheries
- Gulf shoreline, marsh and seafloor — At least 2,100 km of shoreline oiled; marsh vegetation reduced along 350–721 miles; an injured seafloor zone of more than 770 square miles around the wellhead. Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees
What happened
In March 2008 BP paid a little over $34 million to the Minerals Management Service for the Mississippi Canyon Block 252 lease, according to the report of the National Commission, and estimated a reservoir of at least 50 million barrels. The Macondo well was an exploration well: BP planned to drill to 20,200 feet to learn about the geology and because it thought it might find a reservoir that would warrant installing production equipment. Transocean's Marianas rig spudded the well in October 2009; hurricane damage ended its work, and the Deepwater Horizon rig arrived on 31 January 2010. The well was not producing on 20 April 2010.
On 20 April 2010 the Deepwater Horizon rig, owned by Transocean, exploded while drilling BP's Macondo well in the Gulf of Mexico. Eleven workers were killed and 17 were injured; the rig sank on 22 April. A capping stack stopped the flow on 15 July 2010, which NOAA counts as 86 days exclusively and 87 days inclusively; the well was declared sealed on 19 September 2010. The US government had estimated about 4.9 million barrels released gross. In January 2015 the federal court found that 4.0 million barrels were released and that 3.19 million reached the Gulf after about 810,000 barrels were collected (NOAA gives about 134 million gallons, which equals 3.19 million barrels). At least 2,100 km of shoreline were oiled. The natural-resource Trustees estimated that 51,600 to 84,500 birds, 4,900 to 7,600 large juvenile and adult sea turtles and 2 to 5 trillion larval fish died.
In January 2013 BP pleaded guilty to 14 criminal counts, including 11 counts of seaman's manslaughter, and agreed to a record $4 billion in payments, of which $2.544 billion went to the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation's Gulf Environmental Benefit Fund. In September 2014 Judge Carl Barbier of the US District Court, E.D. Louisiana (MDL 2179) found that the discharge resulted from BP's gross negligence and willful misconduct, and apportioned fault 67% to BP, 30% to Transocean and 3% to Halliburton, finding Transocean and Halliburton negligent. In October 2015 the US and five Gulf states announced a civil settlement of about $20.8 billion, which the court entered as a consent decree on 4 April 2016: a $5.5 billion Clean Water Act penalty, $8.1 billion in natural-resource damages (plus up to $700 million), other federal claims and $5.9 billion for states and local governments. BP's RESTORE deposits of about $4.4 billion are paid in installments from 2017 to 2031. No individual received a prison sentence.
BP shared costs with partners and contractors: Anadarko paid BP $4.0 billion and transferred its interest in the Macondo well and lease (October 2011), MOEX agreed to pay $1.065 billion (May 2011) and Cameron paid $250 million (January 2012), of which $167.5 million was funded by Cameron's insurers. BP bought little insurance: its 2010 Form 20-F says the group generally restricts its purchase of insurance to situations required for legal or contractual reasons, and that losses are borne as they arise. Transocean received $560 million from its hull insurers for the rig and recorded a $267 million gain. BP's attempt to claim as an additional insured under $750 million of Transocean's liability policies failed in the Texas Supreme Court in February 2015, and in May 2015 BP agreed to drop its attempts to recover and to pay Transocean $125 million for legal fees. Estimates of the insured market loss varied widely, and no final figure is on record.
BP recorded a cumulative pre-tax charge of $67.0 billion ($66.958 billion) by the end of 2018 and a 2010 tax credit of $11.857 billion. From 2011 to 2025 its profit attributable to shareholders totalled $75.4 billion. By the end of 2025 the Trustees had received $5.54 billion in natural-resource payments and spent $2.44 billion. Official documents from 2024 to 2026 do not describe any injured resource as restored or recovered. NOAA's June 2024 stock assessment gave a maximum reduction of 45% for the Barataria Bay bottlenose dolphin stock and 35 years to recover to 95% of baseline numbers, and said disease conditions had persisted and worsened. In July 2025 Louisiana agreed to terminate the Mid-Barataria Sediment Diversion project, cutting its budget from $2.26 billion to the $618.52 million already disbursed; unused funds are to be available for future Deepwater Horizon restoration in Louisiana. In December 2025 BP was the top bidder in a Gulf lease sale, for 51 blocks. The Trustees' next programmatic review is expected in late 2026.
- 2008BP pays a little over $34m for the Mississippi Canyon Block 252 lease (March)
- 2010Explosion 20 Apr, 11 workers killed; rig sinks 22 Apr; well capped 15 Jul; BP suspends dividend (Jun); well declared sealed 19 Sep; Transocean receives $560m hull insurance; BP records a $11.9bn tax credit
- 2011MOEX agrees to pay BP $1.065bn (20 May); Anadarko pays BP $4bn (Oct); first court ruling against BP on Transocean's insurance (Nov)
- 2012Cameron pays $250m into the $20bn trust (Jan); BP criminal plea agreed (Nov); SEC settlement $525m; EPA suspends BP from new federal contracts; class settlement approved 21 Dec
- 2013BP sentenced 29 Jan ($4bn); Transocean pays $1.4bn ($400m criminal plus $1bn civil)
- 2014Phase One ruling 4 Sep: gross negligence and willful misconduct, fault BP 67%, Transocean 30%, Halliburton 3%; Halliburton $1.1bn class settlement
- 2015Phase Two ruling on volume, 15 Jan (3.19m barrels); Texas Supreme Court rules against BP on insurance, 13 Feb; BP report says the Gulf is returning to baseline and NOAA disputes it, 16 Mar; BP and Transocean settle, 20 May; $20.8bn settlement announced 5 Oct
- 2016Consent decree entered 4 Apr
- 2017First annual natural-resource payment (April); Halliburton loses insurance arbitration (Dec)
- 2018BP's cumulative pre-tax charge reaches $66.958bn
- 2019Texas Supreme Court rules on Anadarko's defence-cost coverage dispute, 25 Jan
- 2024NOAA stock assessment for Barataria Bay dolphins (Jun): maximum reduction 45%, 35 years to recover
- 2025Mid-Barataria sediment diversion termination agreed (Jul); Treasury RESTORE tables show $3,887.3m allocated and $2,593.0m obligated or transferred (1 Oct); $2.44bn of natural-resource money spent by year-end; BP leads Gulf lease sale, 51 blocks (Dec)
- 2026US Interior Department approves BP's Kaskida project in the Gulf (Mar); next Trustee programmatic review expected late 2026
- 2031Last scheduled natural-resource payment
What was said
“the largest criminal resolution in U.S. history”
“the largest civil penalty in the history of environmental law”
“the largest environmental penalty of all time”
“BP's conduct was reckless. Transocean's conduct was negligent. Halliburton's conduct was negligent.”
“Losses are borne as they arise, rather than being spread over time through insurance premiums.”
“we recognized a gain on the loss of the rig in the amount of $267 million”
“BP Exploration & Production, Inc. ('BPXP') is subject to enhanced civil penalties under the Clean Water Act ('CWA'), 33 U.S.C. § 1321(b)(7)(D), as the discharge of oil was the result of BPXP's gross negligence and BPXP's willful misconduct.”
“generally restricts its purchase of insurance to situations where this is required for legal or contractual reasons”
“Deepwater Horizon had an insured value of $560 million, and there was no deductible for the total loss of the unit.”
“agreed to discontinue its attempts to recover as an additional insured”
Where accounts differ
Each party's account, side by side, with its source. The record does not settle these points; it shows them.
Described the accident as multi-party, with a large share attributed to the drilling contractor and the cement company.
Found gross negligence and willful misconduct by BP; apportioned fault 67% BP, 30% Transocean (negligent), 3% Halliburton (negligent).
US District Court, E.D. LouisianaIts 16 March 2015 report said the Gulf had returned to baseline, fish populations were sound and heavily oiled marsh shoreline had fallen from 86 to 0.7 miles.
Said the same day that BP had misinterpreted and misapplied the data and that effects would most likely last for generations.
Said BP had used the data selectively.
Up to a 51% decrease; about 39 years to recover without restoration.
Deepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees51% mean decline; about 32 years to recover under the refined model.
Marine Mammal Commission45% maximum reduction; 35 years to recover to 95% of baseline.
NOAA FisheriesClaimed additional-insured status under Transocean's $750 million of policies.
Carrier Management / ReutersArgued the cover reached only liabilities Transocean assumed in the drilling contract, which excluded subsurface pollution.
Rivkin RadlerHeld BP is an additional insured only for liabilities Transocean assumed (above-surface pollution), so it has no coverage for subsurface pollution.
Rivkin RadlerEstimated about 4.9 million barrels released gross.
NOAA Office of Response and RestorationFound 4.0 million barrels released and 3.19 million discharged after subtracting about 810,000 barrels collected.
KUNC (AP)How it looked
Shown
- The largest criminal resolution in US historyUS Department of Justice, on BP's guilty plea (2013) · US Department of Justice
- The largest civil penalty in the history of environmental lawUS Department of Justice (2015) · US Department of Justice
- The largest environmental penalty of all timeLoretta Lynch, US Attorney General (2016) · US Department of Justice
- Press wording "the largest environmental settlement in US history" was not used by the DOJ.Press reports
- In May 2010, while the well was still flowing, BP's then chief executive said, as paraphrased in the reports reviewed, that the Gulf was a very large ocean and that the environmental impact would most likely be very modest.Tony Hayward, then CEO of BP
- On 16 March 2015 BP's own report said the Gulf had returned to its pre-spill baseline, fish populations were sound and heavily oiled marsh shoreline had fallen from 86 miles to 0.7 miles; BP's vice president for environmental restoration said predictions of catastrophe had not come true.BP report, 16 March 2015
Recorded
- BP booked a $67.0bn cumulative pre-tax charge by end-2018 and an $11.857bn tax credit in 2010.
- The $5.5bn civil penalty is not tax-deductible; US PIRG estimated that $15.3bn of the $20.8bn settlement could be deducted, a tax benefit to BP of about $5.35bn.
- Natural-resource money spent by end-2025: $2.44bn of up to $8.8bn (about 28%).
- BP profit attributable to shareholders, 2011-2025: $75.4bn; dividends and buybacks 2021-2025: $56.2bn.
- No Trustee document from 2024-2026 describes any injured resource as "restored" or "recovered"; the Trustees' next programmatic review is expected in late 2026.
- Barataria Bay dolphins: up to 45% reduction, 35 years to recover (NOAA, 2024); the 2016 Trustee estimate was up to 51% and about 39 years.
- Fault: BP 67%, Transocean 30%, Halliburton 3% (court, 2014); no individual imprisoned.
- On the day BP's 2015 report appeared, NOAA said BP had misinterpreted and misapplied the data and that effects would most likely last for generations; the head of Louisiana's coastal protection agency said BP had used the data selectively. The report had not been peer reviewed and the official damage assessment was not finished.
- The Nature Conservancy accepted about $10 million in cash and land from BP over the years and gave BP a seat on its International Leadership Council (reported 24 May 2010); Conservation International received $2 million from BP, and BP's chief executive John Browne sat on its board from 2000 to 2006.
Who gained
Reached nature or the ground
Gained elsewhere
Responses on record
- bp: BP's internal investigation report described the blowout as a multi-party accident, assigning a large share to the drilling contractor and the cement company.
- bp (2015-03-16): Reported on 16 March 2015 that the Gulf had returned to its pre-spill baseline, fish populations were sound, and heavily oiled marsh shoreline had fallen from 86 miles to 0.7 miles; its vice president for environmental restoration said predictions of catastrophe had not come true.
- bp (2012-02): In its February 2012 filing said it was seeking reimbursement for personal injury and death claims under its insurance and indemnity rights in the Transocean contract and that no recovery amounts had been recognized. · BP p.l.c. (SEC filing)
- bp (2015-05-20): Agreed to discontinue its attempts to recover as an additional insured under Transocean's policies and to pay Transocean $125 million for legal fees; Transocean received the payment on 3 July 2015. · Transocean (SEC filing)
- transocean (2011): Reported receiving $560 million in cash proceeds from insurance recoveries in 2010 and recognizing a $267 million gain on the loss of the rig. · Transocean (SEC filing)
- anadarko (2012): Reported that it paid $4.0 billion and transferred its interest in the Macondo well and lease to BP, accepted by BP in satisfaction of $6.1 billion of invoices, partly offset by a $163 million gain from insurance recoveries in the fourth quarter of 2011. · Anadarko (SEC filing)
- moex (2011-05-20): Agreed on 20 May 2011 to pay BP $1.065 billion; BP said it would apply this to the $20 billion trust and indemnifies MOEX for compensatory claims, excluding fines, penalties and punitive damages. · Oil & Gas Journal
- halliburton (2014-09): Settled the MDL claims for about $1.1 billion (September 2014). · Halliburton (SEC filing)
- halliburton (2016): Sought reimbursement from its insurers; carriers on the final layer of about $200 million refused. · Halliburton (SEC filing)
- bp (2011-03-02): Its 2010 Form 20-F said it generally restricts its purchase of insurance to situations where this is required for legal or contractual reasons, and that losses are borne as they arise. · BP p.l.c. (SEC filing)
- transocean (2015-05): Paid its class settlement of $211.75 million from cash on hand, not insurance (final approval 15 February 2017). · Transocean (SEC filing)
- chubb (2017-12): Argued that Halliburton's settlement was not a reasonable settlement; the arbitration award of 5 December 2017 went to Chubb. · UK Supreme Court
In court and with insurers
Lawsuits and rulings
- 2012–2013Guilty plea$4bn fineUnited States v. BP Exploration & Production (criminal plea)US District Court, E.D. Louisiana (Judge Sarah Vance) · Criminal · US Department of Justice → BP Exploration & Production Inc.
BP pleaded guilty to 14 counts, including 11 felony counts of seaman's manslaughter and one of obstruction of Congress, and was sentenced on 29 January 2013 to $4bn in fines and penalties and five years' probation. The criminal payments included $2.544bn for the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation's Gulf Environmental Benefit Fund. US Department of Justice
- 2013–2013Guilty plea$400m fineUnited States v. Transocean Deepwater (criminal plea)US District Court, E.D. Louisiana (Judge Milazzo) · Criminal · US Department of Justice → Transocean Deepwater Inc.
Transocean pleaded guilty to one Clean Water Act count; the plea was accepted on 14 February 2013. US Department of Justice
- 2013Settled$1bn settlementUnited States v. Transocean (Clean Water Act civil penalty)US District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Civil · United States → Transocean
Transocean agreed to a $1bn civil Clean Water Act penalty in January 2013, alongside its $400m criminal plea. US Department of Justice
- 2013–2013Guilty plea$0.2m fineUnited States v. Halliburton Energy Services (criminal plea)US District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Criminal · US Department of Justice → Halliburton Energy Services
Halliburton pleaded guilty in July 2013 and paid a $200,000 fine, plus a voluntary $55m to NFWF.
- 2012Settled$525m settlementSEC v. BP p.l.c.US Securities and Exchange Commission · Regulatory · US Securities and Exchange Commission → BP p.l.c.
BP agreed in November 2012 to pay a $525m civil penalty over three years.
- 2012–2014SettledEPA suspension of BP from federal contractsUS Environmental Protection Agency · Administrative · US Environmental Protection Agency → BP
EPA suspended BP from new federal contracts on 28 November 2012, citing "lack of business integrity"; an administrative agreement resolved the suspension on 13 March 2014. US Environmental Protection Agency
- 2014Claimant wonIn re Oil Spill by the Oil Rig Deepwater Horizon (MDL 2179), Phase OneUS District Court, E.D. Louisiana (Judge Carl Barbier) · Civil · United States, Gulf states and private plaintiffs → BP Exploration & Production, BP America Production, Transocean, Halliburton
The court found on 4 September 2014 that the discharge resulted from BPXP's gross negligence and willful misconduct, raising the Clean Water Act maximum from $1,100 per barrel to about four times that, and apportioned fault 67% BP, 30% Transocean and 3% Halliburton. US District Court, E.D. Louisiana
- 2014Defendant wonMDL 2179, BP motion to amend Phase One findingsUS District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Civil · BP → United States and other plaintiffs
BP's motion to amend the findings or for a new trial was denied on 13 November 2014.
- 2015Claimant wonMDL 2179, Phase Two (quantity of oil)US District Court, E.D. Louisiana (Judge Carl Barbier) · Civil · United States → BP Exploration & Production
On 15 January 2015 the court found 4.0 million barrels left the reservoir and 3.19 million reached the Gulf; at trial the US had argued 4.2 million and BP 2.45 million. KUNC (AP)
- 2016SettledBP appeal of the Phase One rulingUS Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit · Appeal · BP → United States and other plaintiffs
The Fifth Circuit held the appeal in abeyance on 22 July 2015; no appellate ruling was found, and the dispute was closed by the 2016 consent decree.
- 2016Settled$20.8bn settlementUnited States and five Gulf states v. BP (consent decree)US District Court, E.D. Louisiana (Judge Carl Barbier) · Civil · United States; Alabama, Florida, Louisiana, Mississippi, Texas → BP Exploration & Production
Announced 5 October 2015 and entered 4 April 2016: a $5.5bn Clean Water Act penalty (80% to RESTORE), $8.1bn natural-resource damages plus up to $700m, other federal claims and up to $5.9bn in state and local economic claims, paid until 2031. US Department of Justice
- 2015Settled$5.9bn settlementGulf states and local governments v. BP (economic claims agreement)Separate agreement with the 2015 settlement · Civil · Five Gulf states and local governments → BP
$4.9bn to the five states and up to $1bn to local governments; about $687.4m had reached 383 local entities by August 2015. US Department of Justice
- 2012Settled$7.8bn settlement (BP estimate, uncapped)Plaintiffs' Steering Committee economic and property damages settlementUS District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Class action · Gulf businesses and individuals (class) → BP
Approved on 21 December 2012; BP's 2012 estimate was about $7.8bn including a $2.3bn seafood fund, and NOAA in 2016 put estimated private-claim payments at $14.8bn. No final paid total was found. NOAA
- 2012SettledMedical benefits class settlementUS District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Class action · Clean-up workers and coastal residents (class) → BP
About 37,000 claims were filed and about 78% were initially rejected; 40 of about 23,000 approved claimants received the top award of $60,700. Fortune
- 2014Settled$1.1bn settlementPunitive-damages and assigned-claims classes v. HalliburtonUS District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Class action · Punitive-damages and assigned-claims classes → Halliburton
Halliburton agreed on 2 September 2014 to pay $1.1bn, including fees, into a trust in three instalments. Halliburton (SEC filing)
- 2015Settled$211.75m settlementPlaintiffs' Steering Committee classes v. TransoceanUS District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Class action · Two plaintiff classes → Transocean
Agreed in May 2015 and given final approval on 15 February 2017; Transocean paid from cash on hand, not insurance. Transocean (SEC filing)
- 2015Claimant won$159.5m fineUnited States v. Anadarko (Clean Water Act penalty)US District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Civil · United States → Anadarko Petroleum
A $159.5m civil penalty was imposed on 30 November 2015 on the 25% well partner and paid in early 2016. NBC News
- 2015DismissedUnited States v. Kaluza and Vidrine (manslaughter counts)US District Court, E.D. Louisiana; Fifth Circuit · Criminal · US Department of Justice → Kaluza and Vidrine, BP well site leaders
The 11 seaman's manslaughter counts were dismissed by the trial court and the dismissal was upheld by the Fifth Circuit in 2015; the involuntary manslaughter counts were later dropped. US Department of Justice
- 2016Guilty pleaUnited States v. Vidrine (Clean Water Act misdemeanor)US District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Criminal · US Department of Justice → Vidrine, BP well site leader
Vidrine pleaded guilty to negligent discharge of oil and was sentenced in April 2016 to 10 months' probation. The Maritime Executive
- 2016Defendant wonUnited States v. Kaluza (Clean Water Act count)US District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Criminal · US Department of Justice → Kaluza, BP well site leader
A jury acquitted Kaluza of the Clean Water Act count in February 2016. US Department of Justice
- 2015Defendant wonUnited States v. RaineyUS District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Criminal · US Department of Justice → Rainey, BP vice-president
Charged with obstruction of Congress and false statements; acquitted by a jury in June 2015. US Department of Justice
- 2013Overturned on appealUnited States v. Mix (obstruction conviction)US District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Criminal · US Department of Justice → Kurt Mix, BP engineer
Mix was convicted of obstruction of justice in December 2013; the conviction was vacated for juror misconduct. US Department of Justice
- 2015Guilty pleaUnited States v. Mix (misdemeanor plea)US District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Criminal · US Department of Justice → Kurt Mix, BP engineer
Mix pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor of damaging a computer and was sentenced in November 2015 to six months' probation. US Department of Justice
- 2010–2011Defendant won$750m claimedIn re Deepwater Horizon: BP as additional insured under Transocean's policies (trial court)US District Court, E.D. Louisiana (MDL 2179) · Civil · BP (with Anadarko and MOEX) → Transocean's insurers
On 15 November 2011 the court limited BP's cover to the scope of Transocean's indemnity in the drilling contract and entered judgment against BP, Anadarko and MOEX. Transocean (SEC filing)
- 2013Overturned on appealIn re Deepwater Horizon: Fifth Circuit ruling for BP (withdrawn)US Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit · Appeal · BP → Transocean's insurers
On 1 March 2013 the Fifth Circuit held BP an "unrestricted additional insured"; it withdrew that opinion on 29 August 2013 and certified questions to the Texas Supreme Court. Transocean (SEC filing)
- 2013–2015Defendant won$750m claimedIn re Deepwater Horizon, No. 13-0670 (BP v. Transocean's insurers)Supreme Court of Texas · Appeal · BP → Ranger Insurance and Transocean's excess insurers (Lloyd's and others)
On 13 February 2015 the court held that BP was an additional insured only for liabilities Transocean assumed in the drilling contract, and so had no cover for subsurface pollution. Rivkin Radler
- 2015Settled$125m paid (by BP, for Transocean's legal fees)BP–Transocean settlementOut of court · Civil · BP → Transocean
Announced 20 May 2015: BP dropped its attempts to recover as an additional insured and paid Transocean $125m for legal fees. Transocean (SEC filing)
- 2011Settled$4bn settlementBP–Anadarko settlement (well costs)Out of court · Civil · BP → Anadarko Petroleum
Anadarko paid BP $4bn and transferred its 25% interest in the well and lease in October 2011, in satisfaction of $6.1bn of invoices. BP pays Anadarko 12.5% of third-party recoveries above $1.5bn, capped at $1.0bn. Anadarko (SEC filing)
- 2011Settled$1.06bn settlementBP–MOEX settlement (well costs)Out of court · Civil · BP → MOEX (Mitsui Oil Exploration)
MOEX agreed on 20 May 2011 to pay BP $1.065bn, which BP said would go to its $20bn trust. BP indemnifies MOEX for compensatory claims, excluding fines, penalties and punitive damages. Oil & Gas Journal
- 2012Settled$250m settlementBP–Cameron settlementOut of court · Civil · BP → Cameron International
Cameron, maker of the blowout preventer, paid BP $250m in January 2012; about $167.5m was funded by its insurers. Cameron (SEC filing)
- 2011Settled$75m settlementBP–Weatherford settlementOut of court · Civil · BP → Weatherford
Reported at $75m; BP's filings combine MOEX and Weatherford payments into its trust at $1,140m. BP p.l.c. (SEC filing)
- 2017Defendant wonHalliburton v. Chubb Bermuda (insurance arbitration)London arbitration (Bermuda Form) · Arbitration · Halliburton → Chubb Bermuda Insurance
A final partial award of 5 December 2017 found for Chubb, which had argued that Halliburton's settlement "was not a reasonable settlement". UK Supreme Court
- 2020DismissedHalliburton v. Chubb Bermuda [2020] UKSC 48UK Supreme Court · Appeal · Halliburton → Chubb Bermuda Insurance
The appeal concerned only arbitrator bias and was dismissed on 27 November 2020. UK Supreme Court
- 2019Claimant wonAnadarko v. Houston Casualty and Lloyd's underwriters, No. 16-1013Supreme Court of Texas · Appeal · Anadarko Petroleum → Houston Casualty and other excess insurers
On 25 January 2019 the court held that the joint-venture cap does not limit Anadarko's defence costs of more than $100m, and sent the case back to the trial court. Hunton Andrews Kurth
Insurers
- 2010Self-insured$700m policy limit; reserves set at limitJupiter Insurance Ltd (BP's captive, Guernsey) → BPStated reason: BP "generally restricts its purchase of insurance to situations where this is required for legal or contractual reasons"
BP self-insured through its captive, which bought no outward reinsurance and covered property damage and business interruption; whether it paid out is not documented. BP's 2010 Form 20-F says the group has borne and will continue to bear the entire burden of its share of property damage, well control, clean-up and third-party liability costs. Business Insurance
- 2010Paid$560m paid (total loss, no deductible)Hull and machinery underwriters → Transocean
Underwriters declared the rig a total loss; Transocean received $560m in cash and recorded a $267m gain on the loss. Further cover of up to $140m each existed for mitigation costs and wreck removal; the contract backlog was about $590m. Transocean (SEC filing)
- 2015Paid$538m recovery of previously incurred lossesTransocean excess liability insurers, layers one to four → Transocean
Insurance first paid crew and contractor injury and death claims; after BP dropped its claim, Transocean recognised $538m and said the fourth layer was exhausted. Transocean (SEC filing)
- 2016In litigation$30m recoveredBermuda market insurers (fifth layer, $250m) → TransoceanStated reason: Insurers "asserted various coverage defenses"; Chubb argued claims were "not reasonably settled"
Transocean issued arbitration notices; it reported about $30m of recoveries in 2016 and none in 2017. The final result was not found. Transocean (SEC filing)
- 2015Claim refused$750m claimed, not paidRanger Insurance ($50m primary) and Lloyd's and other excess underwriters ($700m) → BP (claimed additional insured on Transocean's policies)Stated reason: BP was an additional insured only for liabilities Transocean assumed in the drilling contract, which excluded subsurface pollution
The insurers won in the Texas Supreme Court in February 2015; BP then dropped its claim. Rivkin Radler
- 2011Paid$163m recovered, booked as gainAnadarko's insurers (not named) → Anadarko Petroleum
Anadarko recognised a $163m gain for insurance recoveries in the fourth quarter of 2011, the year it paid BP $4bn. Anadarko (SEC filing)
- 2019Partly paid$37.5m paid (25% of limit)Lloyd's underwriters and Houston Casualty (excess, $150m limit) → Anadarko PetroleumStated reason: Joint-venture liability cap
The insurers paid $37.5m; the Texas Supreme Court ruled in 2019 that the cap does not limit defence costs and sent the case back. Hunton Andrews Kurth
- 2015Partly paid$403m reimbursed of about $1.5bn costsHalliburton general liability programme ($600m) → Halliburton
Of about $1.5bn in settlement and legal costs, $403m was reimbursed under Halliburton's insurance programme. Halliburton (SEC filing)
- 2017Claim refused$200m not reimbursed (about)Chubb Bermuda (top layer) → HalliburtonStated reason: "Halliburton's settlement was not a reasonable settlement"; Chubb had not consented
Carriers on the final layer refused to reimburse about $200m; the London arbitration ended in Chubb's favour in December 2017. Halliburton (SEC filing)
- 2012Paid$167.5m paid toward $250m settlement with BPCameron's insurers → Cameron International
The only documented insurer-funded money that went into the BP trust that also funds natural-resource damages; Cameron pursued a further $50m from one non-consenting insurer. Cameron (SEC filing)
- 2010No policy found$600m estimated ultimate claims (upper end of $300–600m)Lloyd's market → Various parties
Lloyd's estimated its ultimate Deepwater Horizon claims at $300m to $600m; Moody's put the total insured market loss at $1.4bn to $3.5bn. The estimate was unchanged from Lloyd's May 2010 announcement. Lloyd's
- 2010No policy found$950m excess liability cover (annual aggregate for the whole fleet)Transocean's commercial excess liability insurers → Transocean
Transocean had $950m of commercial excess liability cover, paid a $65m deductible and generally retains the risk above $1.0bn. How much of the layer was paid and to whom is not on record. Transocean (SEC filing)
- 2010No policy foundUpstream energy insurance market (Willis Energy Market Review) → Deepwater Horizon and Aban Pearl losses
Claims to the market were "well in excess of $1.2 billion"; the two rig losses cost upstream insurers $795m within one month. Insurance Journal
- 2010No policy foundMunich Re → Deepwater Horizon reinsured losses
Reported a potential loss of over $128m. Atlas Magazine
- 2010No policy foundSwiss Re → Deepwater Horizon reinsured losses
Estimated industry losses at $1.5bn-$3.5bn and its own participation at about $200m. Atlas Magazine
- 2010No policy foundHannover Re → Deepwater Horizon reinsured losses
Expected a claim of about EUR 40m ($53.5m) in May 2010; later reported as $51m. Business Insurance
What nature saw
Nature's report opens this page. Below: further outcomes measured on the ground.
What we don't know
Nature
Insurers
- Unclear Lloyd's market: no decision on record.
- Unclear Transocean's commercial excess liability insurers: no decision on record.
- Unclear Upstream energy insurance market (Willis Energy Market Review): no decision on record.
- Unclear Munich Re: no decision on record.
- Unclear Swiss Re: no decision on record.
- Unclear Hannover Re: no decision on record.
Accounts
Record
- None on record The tax deduction BP actually took on the 2016 settlement has not been disclosed; the $5.35bn tax benefit is a US PIRG estimate.
- Unclear Whether BP's captive insurer Jupiter paid any of its $700m limit, and to whom.
- Not disclosed Final totals paid under the economic-loss and medical class settlements: not published.
- Unclear Actual RESTORE Act spending: only allocations and obligations are published.
- None on record The NFWF awarded total and its date ($1.7bn on the live page vs $2.3bn in an older snapshot).
- None on record The final outcome of Transocean's arbitration with its fifth-layer Bermuda insurers.
- None on record BP's appeal of the 2014 gross-negligence ruling: no appellate ruling found; it appears to have been closed by the 2016 settlement.
- Unclear Whether any insurance money reached restoration: the only documented link is $167.5m from Cameron's insurers paid into the BP trust that also funds natural-resource damages; it cannot be traced to specific spending.
- None on record The exact rig dayrate in force in April 2010: about $500,000 a day is widely cited, but no primary document was found.
- Disputed Estimates of the Barataria Bay dolphin decline differ: up to 51% (Trustees, 2016), 51% (Marine Mammal Commission), 45% (NOAA, June 2024).
- Disputed Estimates of the oil volume differ: about 4.9 million barrels gross (US government), 4.0 million released and 3.19 million discharged (court, January 2015).
- None on record BP's own recovery from Transocean's policies: no document shows BP recovered anything; BP's February 2012 filing said it was seeking reimbursement and that no recovery amounts had been recognised.
- None on record The final insured market loss: estimates vary, including Moody's $1.4bn to $3.5bn, Swiss Re $1.5bn to $3.5bn and Lloyd's own-market claims of $300m to $600m.
- Insufficient Reported but not independently verified: that bacteria consumed at least 200,000 tonnes of oil and gas while the fate of about 40% of the hydrocarbons is unknown.
- Disputed Sources reviewed give different figures for the other federal claims element of the 2015 settlement: $250m in one reading of the Justice Department fact sheet and about $600m in another.
Did the harm stop?
The flow stopped on 15 July 2010, 87 days after the explosion; the well was declared sealed on 19 September 2010. Natural-resource payments continue until 2031, and no injured resource has been declared recovered.
Who paid?
Eleven workers who died and 17 injured; Gulf wildlife and coastal communities; US taxpayers through tax deductions on non-penalty payments, according to an advocacy-group estimate.
Sources
Company or project
- BP Annual Report on Form 20-F 2018: Gulf of Mexico oil spill noteBP p.l.c. (SEC filing) · 2019
- BP Annual Report on Form 20-F 2010BP p.l.c. (SEC filing) · 2011-03-02
- BP fourth quarter and full year 2010 resultsBP p.l.c. (SEC filing) · 2011-02-01
- BP fourth quarter and full year 2025 resultsBP p.l.c. (SEC filing) · 2026-02-10
- Transocean Form 10-K 2010Transocean (SEC filing) · 2011
- Transocean Form 10-Q, Q2 2015Transocean (SEC filing) · 2015
- Transocean filing: Macondo settlement with BPTransocean (SEC filing) · 2015-05-20
- Anadarko Petroleum Form 10-K 2011Anadarko (SEC filing) · 2012
- Halliburton Form 10-K 2015Halliburton (SEC filing) · 2016
- Cameron International Form 10-K 2011Cameron (SEC filing) · 2012
- Lloyd's Interim Report 2010Lloyd's · 2010
- BP Form 6-K: dividend suspensionBP p.l.c. (SEC filing) · 2010-06-16
- BP Form 6-K: Gulf of Mexico statementBP p.l.c. (SEC filing) · 2009-09-02
- BP third quarter 2011 resultsBP p.l.c. (SEC filing) · 2011
- Halliburton Form 10-Q, Q3 2014Halliburton (SEC filing) · 2014
- Halliburton Form 10-Q, Q2 2016Halliburton (SEC filing) · 2016
- Transocean Form 10-Q, Q1 2016Transocean (SEC filing) · 2016
- Transocean Form 10-K 2013Transocean (SEC filing) · 2014
- BP fourth quarter 2011 results (Gulf of Mexico oil spill)BP p.l.c. (SEC filing) · 2012-02-07
- BP Annual Report on Form 20-F 2022BP p.l.c. (SEC filing) · 2023
- BP third quarter 2010 resultsBP p.l.c. (SEC filing) · 2010-11-02
- Anadarko 2010 Form 10-KAnadarko (SEC filing) · 2011
Government and regulators
- BP Exploration and Production Inc. pleads guilty, sentenced to pay record $4 billion for crimesUS Department of Justice · 2013-01-29
- U.S. and five Gulf states reach historic settlement with BPUS Department of Justice · 2015-10-05
- Attorney General Loretta E. Lynch statement on BP settlementUS Department of Justice · 2016-04-04
- Deepwater Horizon consent decree fact sheetUS Department of Justice · 2015-10
- Programmatic Damage Assessment and Restoration Plan: OverviewDeepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees · 2016-04
- PDARP Chapter 2: Incident overviewDeepwater Horizon Trustees · 2016
- Deepwater Horizon Trustee Council 2025 annual financial summaryDeepwater Horizon Trustee Council · 2026
- Common bottlenose dolphin, Barataria Bay stock assessmentNOAA Fisheries · 2024-06
- United States v. BP Exploration and Production, Inc. et al. (case page)US Department of Justice · 2016
- Transocean plea agreement (DOJ release)US Department of Justice · 2013-01
- Gulf Coast Restoration Trust Fund allocation tablesUS Department of the Treasury · 2025-10-01
- Louisiana moves to terminate Mid-Barataria Sediment Diversion projectDeepwater Horizon Trustees · 2025-07
- Audit of Gulf Coast Claims Facility results in $64 million in additional paymentsUS Department of Justice · 2012-04
- National Commission on the BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill, Chapter 4National Commission (hosted by Mother Jones) · 2011
- EPA suspends BP from new federal contractsUS Environmental Protection Agency · 2012-11-28
- Deepwater Horizon oil spill (significant incidents)NOAA Office of Response and Restoration ·
- Affected Gulf resourcesDeepwater Horizon Natural Resource Damage Assessment Trustees ·
Courts
- In re Oil Spill by the Oil Rig Deepwater Horizon, Phase One Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawUS District Court, E.D. Louisiana · 2014-09-04
- Halliburton Company v Chubb Bermuda Insurance Ltd [2020] UKSC 48UK Supreme Court · 2020-11-27
- Consent decree as filed with BP's FY2015 Form 20-FBP (SEC filing) · 2016
Press and investigations
- BP can tap captive for $700m in loss of rigBusiness Insurance · 2010-05-09
- Deepwater Horizon supervisor gets probationThe Maritime Executive · 2016-04
- BP can write off $15.3 billion of Gulf oil spill settlementAccounting Today · 2015-10-07
- Anadarko Petroleum hit with $159M fine for Deepwater Horizon disasterNBC News · 2015-11
- BP oil spill: most ordinary people got nothing from the medical settlementFortune · 2024-04-19
- BP, Mitsui reach $1 billion settlement for oil spillOil & Gas Journal · 2011-05-20
- Judge's ruling on BP oil spill is key to upcoming trialKUNC (AP) · 2015-01-16
- Moody's reports liability limits of $1.61B in oil spillBusiness Insurance · 2010-06-03
- BP tax credit 2010NBC News · 2010
- Texas Supreme Court ruling on BP's additional-insured claim (via Carrier Management / Reuters)Carrier Management / Reuters · 2015-02-15
- Willis Energy Market Review on rig losses (via Insurance Journal)Insurance Journal · 2010-06-04
- Insurers, reinsurers start assessing rig explosion lossesBusiness Insurance · 2010-05-02
- Judge finalizes $20.8 billion penalty for Deepwater Horizon oil disaster (via AP)Ecomagazine · 2016-04
Communities and civil society
- Gulf Environmental Benefit FundNational Fish and Wildlife Foundation · 2026
Researchers
- Barataria Bay dolphin population trajectory analysis (Schwacke et al.)Marine Mammal Commission · 2021
- Dolphin population will take 40 years to recover from Deepwater Horizon disasterUniversity of St Andrews · 2017-02-13
- Study shows oil impacts on deep-sea coral colonies seven years after Deepwater HorizonGulf of Mexico Research Initiative · 2018-11-27
Connected cases
- Net-Zero Insurance Alliance collapse and insurers’ fossil underwriting Global · 2021–2025
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Excess insurers on Transocean's liability programme; market loss estimate $300–600m; there: Insurance market; left NZIA 26 May 2023
- Chubb Global Markets (Insurer) — here: Halliburton's top-layer insurer (Chubb Bermuda); won arbitration; there: Not an NZIA member; adopted oil and gas standard 2023
- Munich Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Founding member; left 31 March 2023
- Swiss Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Founding member; left May 2023
- Hannover Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Left NZIA 19 April 2023
- EACOP pipeline: insurers decline, construction continues Uganda / Tanzania · 2021–2026
- Chubb Global Markets (Insurer) — here: Halliburton's top-layer insurer (Chubb Bermuda); won arbitration; there: Ruled out cover (April 2025); listed as a holdout in 2024
- Munich Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Ruled out cover (April 2022)
- Swiss Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Ruled out cover (2021)
- Hannover Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Ruled out reinsurance (March 2022)
- Exxon Valdez: the spill, insurance and court cases United States · 1989–2015
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Excess insurers on Transocean's liability programme; market loss estimate $300–600m; there: Lead of 150+ excess insurers; refused cover, paid $780m after suit
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: Prosecutor and civil claimant
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Federal regulator in the 1991 settlement
- NOAA (Public authority) — here: Lead scientific trustee agency; there: Federal agency reporting on residual oil
- Insurers of the Carmichael coal mine Australia · 2015–2025
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Excess insurers on Transocean's liability programme; market loss estimate $300–600m; there: Market whose members insured the mine from 2019
- Munich Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Reinsurer that said it would not support the mine (Dec 2018)
- Swiss Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Reinsurer that said it would not support the mine (Dec 2018)
- Hannover Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Reinsurer listed as having ruled out the mine
- Coral reef parametric insurance, Quintana Roo Mexico · 2018–2026
- Swiss Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Developed the initial solution; named as insurer or reinsurer by different sources
- Hannover Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Reinsurer of the 2020 renewal (per Reinsurance News)
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Co-designer of the cover; author of the July 2026 case study
- Mosaic settles US hazardous-waste case over phosphogypsum handling United States · 2015
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: Co-signatory of the settlement
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator that inspected the sites and signed the settlement
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Conservation organisation listing Mosaic as a corporate partner
- Trans Mountain pipeline insurers (Canada) Canada · 2018–2024
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Excess insurers on Transocean's liability programme; market loss estimate $300–600m; there: Insurance market; syndicates on the 2019–20 policy
- Chubb Global Markets (Insurer) — here: Halliburton's top-layer insurer (Chubb Bermuda); won arbitration; there: Insurer through Chubb European Group; refused cover in September 2021
- Munich Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Insurer through Temple Insurance; reviewed its contract
- Vale Brumadinho dam collapse Brazil · 2019–2027
- Chubb Global Markets (Insurer) — here: Halliburton's top-layer insurer (Chubb Bermuda); won arbitration; there: Lead property insurer (press reports)
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (Public authority) — here: $525m settlement with BP; there: US securities regulator; $55.9m settlement
- Swiss Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Property insurer, Swiss Re Corporate Solutions (press reports)
- Bolivian carbon scheme claimed 55 million tonnes; review found at most 5.8 million Bolivia · 1997–2010
- BP (Company) — here: Well operator and lease holder; pleaded guilty; paid $20.8bn civil settlement; self-insured; there: company; partner in the scheme; donor to TNC
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP
- Gulf of Mexico dead zone (Mississippi nutrient runoff) United States · 1985–2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Clean Water Act regulator
- NOAA (Public authority) — here: Lead scientific trustee agency; there: Funds and reports the annual survey
- Kerr-McGee / Anadarko fraudulent transfer settlement United States · 2014–2015
- Anadarko Petroleum (Company) — here: 25% well partner; paid BP $4bn; $159.5m civil penalty; there: Parent of the defendant subsidiaries; paid the settlement
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: Announced the settlement
- Los Angeles wildfires cause $41bn insured loss; 75% of survivors underinsured United States · 2025
- Ohio HB6 bribery scandal United States · 2017–2026
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: Prosecuted; recorded a $230m payment by the company
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (Public authority) — here: $525m settlement with BP; there: Recorded a $100m payment by the company
- Roundup litigation, settlements and legal shield (Bayer/Monsanto) United States · 2009–2026
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: Supported Monsanto in Durnell
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Approved the Roundup label; said it would not accept a cancer warning
- The Metals Company deep-sea nodule mining in the Clarion-Clipperton Zone (NOAA permit route) International waters (Pacific Ocean) · 2011
- TNC Hawaii coral reef parametric insurance United States · 2022–2026
- Munich Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Insurer (Munich Re Group)
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Policyholder
- US Supreme Court blocks state cancer-warning suits against pesticide makers United States · 2026
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: Supported Monsanto in the case
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Approved the labels; announced the paraquat review
- 1,4-dioxane in Tide: Prop 65 settlement and New York limit United States · 2011–2024
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator; revised risk determination
- 3M PFOS: internal evidence, EPA penalty and Minnesota settlement United States · 1979–2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator; TSCA charge closed 2006
- ADM Decatur carbon storage site leaks about 8,000 tons, EPA finds United States · 2023–2024
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: regulator that found a violation
- AES coal ash sold as road fill in Guayama, Puerto Rico; arsenic above standard United States · 2021
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Federal regulator promising action
- After Sackett ruling, NRDC says at least 60% of individual wetlands are unprotected United States · 2023
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Defendant in Sackett; named in reported 2025 and 2026 proposals to narrow the test (not verified)
- Bahamas debt-for-nature swap Bahamas · 2024
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Conservation organisation involved in the transaction
- Barbados debt-for-nature swap Barbados · 2022
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Guarantor (US$50m)
- Belize blue bond Belize · 2021–2041
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Lender (via subsidiary)
- Bezos Earth Fund: first grants and SBTi funding United States · 2020–2026
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Recipient of $100m (first round)
- Biomas restoration initiative Brazil · 2022
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Nature NGO; director Sérgio Rial was chairman of Santander Brasil when it co-founded Biomas
- Bloomberg, Steyer and Bezos money shapes coal and nature campaigns United States · 2008–2026
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Environmental group that received Bezos Earth Fund money
- BP “Beyond Petroleum” campaign and carbon footprint calculator United Kingdom · 2000–2025
- BP (Company) — here: Well operator and lease holder; pleaded guilty; paid $20.8bn civil settlement; self-insured; there: Launched the “Beyond Petroleum” brand and the carbon footprint calculator
- BP acquires majority stake in Finite Carbon, a US forest carbon developer United States · 2020
- BP (Company) — here: Well operator and lease holder; pleaded guilty; paid $20.8bn civil settlement; self-insured; there: acquirer of a majority stake in Finite Carbon
- BP and Eni do not declare gas flared at Iraq's Rumaila field, citing non-operator status Iraq · 2021–2022
- BP (Company) — here: Well operator and lease holder; pleaded guilty; paid $20.8bn civil settlement; self-insured; there: Non-operator; does not declare Rumaila gas flaring
- BP's Gulf spill used Corexit; Nalco board had ex-BP and Exxon executives United States · date not stated
- BP (Company) — here: Well operator and lease holder; pleaded guilty; paid $20.8bn civil settlement; self-insured; there: Company responsible for the spill response and dispersant choice
- California v. ExxonMobil: plastics recycling claims and the Baytown plant United States · 2021–2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Rejected the mass balance method for its Safer Choice label, per ProPublica
- Chemours spin-off liabilities United States · 2015–2025
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator in the December 2005 PFOA case
- COP28 decision promoted carbon capture and left room for transition fuels United Arab Emirates · 2023
- BP (Company) — here: Well operator and lease holder; pleaded guilty; paid $20.8bn civil settlement; self-insured; there: Member of the Global CCS Institute; three of six executives worked or work here
- Court reverses $60 million punitive award in dicamba case United States · 2015–2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Approved over-the-top dicamba use for 2026 and 2027
- Danone, Unilever and BP scaled back sustainability goals between 2021 and 2025 Global · 2021–2025
- BP (Company) — here: Well operator and lease holder; pleaded guilty; paid $20.8bn civil settlement; self-insured; there: Oil company that cut low-carbon investment in 2025
- Dark Basin hacking of climate groups (#ExxonKnew) United States · 2023
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: Prosecuting authority (Southern District of New York)
- Deep-sea mining: TMC, NORI, the NOAA permit and the ISA International waters (Pacific Ocean) · 2022–2026
- NOAA (Public authority) — here: Lead scientific trustee agency; there: US regulator receiving the application
- Deutsche Bank's DWS paid penalties in US and Germany over ESG claims Germany · 2023–2025
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (Public authority) — here: $525m settlement with BP; there: Imposed 19 million dollar penalty in 2023
- Diamond Shamrock Lister Avenue dioxin, Passaic River United States · 1984–1993
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Selected the 2016 lower Passaic remedy
- Dicamba drift (Bader Farms) and EPA re-registration United States · 2015–2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator; re-registered dicamba in February 2026
- DuPont PFOA (C8) at Washington Works, Parkersburg, and the Tennant farm United States · 1981–2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator; 2005 penalty
- El Salvador debt-for-nature swap El Salvador · 2024–2025
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Not named for this transaction; a JPMorgan executive sits on its board
- EPA repeals 2009 greenhouse gas endangerment finding on legal grounds United States · 2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Issued the repeal
- Former EPA chief Lisa Jackson named interim chair of Conservation International United States · 2012–2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Withdrew the Range Resources emergency order in 2012
- Fresh Del Monte closure of four Costa Rica banana farms Costa Rica · 2019
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (Public authority) — here: $525m settlement with BP; there: Recipient of the company's quarterly filing
- Gabon debt-for-nature swap Gabon · 2023
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Sponsor of the project
- Galápagos debt-for-nature swap Ecuador · 2023–2041
- Chubb Global Markets (Insurer) — here: Halliburton's top-layer insurer (Chubb Bermuda); won arbitration; there: Reinsurer
- Galápagos debt-for-nature swap used US$656 million of US political risk insurance Ecuador · 2023
- Chubb Global Markets (Insurer) — here: Halliburton's top-layer insurer (Chubb Bermuda); won arbitration; there: Reinsurer to DFC, per its release
- GE ran a 'Let Nature Clean Up the Hudson' campaign against EPA dredging United States · 2009–2015
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator that ordered and certified the dredging
- GenX chemical found in Cape Fear River, a DuPont and Chemours replacement for PFOA United States · 2009
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Found in 2021 that GenX was more toxic than previously thought
- Greens report: parts of German glyphosate assessment copied Monsanto file Germany · 2015–2025
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: US regulator; former staff moved to Monsanto; Rowland remark reported
- Hanford contractors settle false-claims suits as cleanup estimates rise United States · 1943–2086
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: Counterparty to the 2016 settlement
- Holcim Geocycle and brand-cement plastic co-processing Global · 2021–2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator; found no meaningful climate benefit from burning plastic instead of coal in kilns (as reported)
- Kenyan water-tower forest evictions followed a 2018 killing by forest guards Kenya · 2016–2024
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: reported water fund operator
- Lead paint public nuisance insurance (Santa Clara) United States · 2000–2024
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Excess insurers on Transocean's liability programme; market loss estimate $300–600m; there: Insurers (Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's) in the ConAgra and NL Industries coverage cases
- Love Canal (New York) United States · 1980–1995
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Excess insurers on Transocean's liability programme; market loss estimate $300–600m; there: Primary insurer; plaintiff in coverage actions
- Make Sunsets stratospheric balloon launches (Mexico) Mexico · 2022–2025
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator that requested information
- MAR Fund Mesoamerican Reef parametric insurance Belize · 2021
- Munich Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Underwriter
- Monsanto faces US bribery charge over Indonesian environmental review Indonesia · 2005
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: prosecuting authority; issued the press release
- Monsanto/Bayer PCB and Roundup insurance suit v AIG United States · 1967–2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator; the sources reviewed say it told Bayer it would not accept a cancer warning
- Montrose DDT insurance case United States · 1947–2020
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: Announced the December 2000 DDT settlement
- Mozambique LNG environmental assessment (ERM) Mozambique · 2014–2024
- Anadarko Petroleum (Company) — here: 25% well partner; paid BP $4bn; $159.5m civil penalty; there: Developer for whom the assessment was prepared; later employer of the assessment's project manager
- Nature Conservancy began $10 million partnership with Dow Chemical in 2011 United States · 2007–2021
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: conservation group; cooperation partner
- Nature Conservancy gas drilling on Texas City Prairie Preserve United States · 1995–2014
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Landowner and driller
- Net Zero Banking Alliance exits and closure International · 2023–2026
- Munich Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Insurer that left the Net-Zero Insurance Alliance in 2023
- NextEra unit ESI Energy admits at least 150 eagle deaths at US wind farms United States · 2012–2022
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: prosecutor that described the permit policy
- Nonylphenol ethoxylates: Swiss ban and EU restriction Switzerland · 1984–2014
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Published the nonylphenol ethoxylate action plan
- North Atlantic right whale deaths and US vessel-speed rule withdrawal United States · 2017–2026
- NOAA (Public authority) — here: Lead scientific trustee agency; there: Regulator and publisher of the Unusual Mortality Event page
- NYSE natural asset company proposal withdrawn United States · 2021–2024
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (Public authority) — here: $525m settlement with BP; there: Regulator that opened a formal review in December 2023
- Palau National Marine Sanctuary Palau · 2015
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Donor group member; former employer of the Agriculture Minister; Micronesia director named in the bill
- Papahānaumokuākea marine debris removal collected 298,180 lb in 2024 United States · 2022–2026
- NOAA (Public authority) — here: Lead scientific trustee agency; there: Co-funder of the 2022–2026 programme
- Pará state pre-sold 12 million REDD+ credits; federal prosecutors sue to cancel Brazil · 2023–2026
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Named by the MPF as having a conflict of interest
- Paraquat bans, UK production for export and Chinese exports United Kingdom · 1989–2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator; interim decision of 2021 and January 2025 announcement
- Paraquat litigation (Syngenta/Chevron) and the Paraquat Papers United States · 1958–2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator; 2021 interim decision and 2025 withdrawal
- PFAS water utility settlements by 3M, DuPont, Chemours and Corteva United States · 2023–2036
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator; drinking-water limits for PFOA and PFOS
- Portland Harbor Superfund cleanup plan (Willamette River, Oregon) United States · 2016–2017
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator; issued the draft plan and the final Superfund decision
- Prestige Spain · 2002–2026
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Excess insurers on Transocean's liability programme; market loss estimate $300–600m; there: Lead hull insurer
- Record cites CIA file on Onassis for 1954 whaling off Peru Peru · 1954–1956
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Excess insurers on Transocean's liability programme; market loss estimate $300–600m; there: reported insurer of the whaling fine (not verified)
- Refugio / Plains Line 901 oil spill (California) United States · 2015–2025
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (Public authority) — here: $525m settlement with BP; there: Questioned the insurance receivable in May 2023
- Rigel scuttling (Calabria) Italy · 1987–2024
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Excess insurers on Transocean's liability programme; market loss estimate $300–600m; there: Insurer named as defrauded in L'Unità
- Salem tanker Senegal (offshore) · 1979–1985
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Excess insurers on Transocean's liability programme; market loss estimate $300–600m; there: Cargo underwriters at Lloyd's (defendant Gibbs)
- Samarco Fundão dam collapse (Mariana): the settlement and the court cases Brazil · 2015–2026
- Chubb Global Markets (Insurer) — here: Halliburton's top-layer insurer (Chubb Bermuda); won arbitration; there: Lead property and business-interruption insurer, as ACE (80%)
- Sellafield decommissioning and Hanford cleanup budgets United States · 1943–2086
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: Government party in the settled cases
- Sengwer evictions from Embobut forest and the EU Water Towers programme (Kenya) Kenya · 2014–2024
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Water fund overlapping Embobut
- Seychelles 2016 debt-for-nature swap listed among TNC Nature Bonds Seychelles · 2016
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Runs the Nature Bonds programme that lists the Seychelles pilot
- Shell reserves overstatement case: investors settle for $352.6 million United States · 2006
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (Public authority) — here: $525m settlement with BP; there: regulator; took no action against three executives in 2006
- Simandou iron ore project, Guinea Guinea · 2008–2026
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (Public authority) — here: $525m settlement with BP; there: Regulator; settlement with Rio Tinto
- Starbase launch site, Boca Chica, Texas: environmental review, penalties and Starship debris United States · 2022–2025
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Federal environmental regulator; found Clean Water Act violations
- Stockholm Convention agrees chlorpyrifos phase-out with 22 uses exempted United States · 2021–2025
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: regulator
- TNC chief scientist urged conservation groups to partner with companies United States · 2011–2015
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Employer of Kareiva; Dow Chemical partner; subject of the essay
- Trump's EPA keeps Biden-era veto on Alaska's Pebble mine United States · 2023–2025
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Issued and reaffirmed the veto
- UK agreed up to £21.7bn over 25 years for two CCS clusters United Kingdom · 2024
- BP (Company) — here: Well operator and lease holder; pleaded guilty; paid $20.8bn civil settlement; self-insured; there: named as a leading company behind the clusters
- US bans DDT in 1972; bald eagle breeding pairs rebound United States · 1972–2019
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: issued the 1972 DDT ban
- US bird flu indemnity and egg prices United States · 2022–2026
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: Egg-price inquiry
- US coal ash ponds, groundwater contamination and EPA delay United States · 2015–2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Regulator
- US indictment alleges Adani solar bribery; three charges later dismissed India · 2024–2026
- US Department of Justice (Government) — here: Prosecutor and civil claimant; there: Prosecution; requested dismissal of three charges
- US power-plant sulfur emissions fell over 95%, EPA says United States · 1990–2022
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: published the programme results
- US quits 66 international bodies including the IPCC; NOAA disaster database closed United States · 2025–2026
- NOAA (Public authority) — here: Lead scientific trustee agency; there: Target of the budget and staffing cuts; its disaster database was closed
- US regulator said Keurig did not disclose recycler doubts about pod recycling United States · 2022–2024
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (Public authority) — here: $525m settlement with BP; there: US regulator
- US SEC switches oil reserve pricing to a 12-month average in 2008 United States · 2008–2021
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (Public authority) — here: $525m settlement with BP; there: regulator that changed the reserve pricing rule
- US Senate probes Nature Conservancy land sales to its own trustees United States · 2003
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: Recipient of BP funding; there: Organisation whose land sales were the subject of the inquiry
- US Superfund tax and funding shortfall United States · 1980–2025
- US Environmental Protection Agency (Public authority) — here: Suspended BP from new federal contracts, 2012–2014; there: Administers Superfund; reports responsible-party commitments
- Venezuela 2026 twin earthquakes insurance gap Venezuela · 2026
- Munich Re (Insurer) — here: Reinsurer; there: Reinsurer; source of the $30 billion loss estimate