Cases / Carbon credits · Bolivia · 1997–2010
Bolivian carbon scheme claimed 55 million tonnes; review found at most 5.8 million
Short record: the main facts, with sources. A full case file has not been prepared.
Nature's voice · report
No measurement of the harm done to me here is on record.
Did nature suffer? Not measured.
Not on record
- The record does not name which of my species, waters, soils or forests were harmed.
The Noel Kempff Climate Action Project in Bolivia was set up by TNC with BP and two electricity companies. Its claimed savings were far above the figure a Greenpeace review found.
What?
The Noel Kempff Climate Action Project claimed 55 million tonnes of savings; a Greenpeace review found at most 5.8 million tonnes. The Nation (J. Hari)
Where?
Bolivia The Nation (J. Hari)
When?
1997-2010 The Nation (J. Hari)
Who?
Gained
- BP — partner in the scheme; ties to TNC included a seat on its International Leadership Council
- The Nature Conservancy (TNC) — accepted about $10 million in cash and land from BP
Lost
None on recordHarmed
None on recordWhy?
Not stated in the sources reviewed.
How?
The 55 million tonne figure was a claim; the 5.8 million tonne figure came from a Greenpeace review, and the sources do not describe the baseline used. The Nation (J. Hari)
6 of 6 questions answered from the record
What happened
The record, in order.
The Noel Kempff Climate Action Project in Bolivia, set up by TNC with BP and two electricity companies, ran from 1997 to 2010 and claimed savings of 55 million tonnes.
A Greenpeace review, reported in The Nation in March 2010, found savings of at most 5.8 million tonnes.
TNC accepted about $10 million in cash and land from BP over several years and gave BP a seat on its International Leadership Council.
BP's chief executive John Browne sat on Conservation International's board from 2000 to 2006, and CI received $2 million from BP.
In court and with insurers
Every proceeding and every insurer decision on record.
Lawsuits and rulings
No court case on record. No court has ruled on this case.
Insurers
No insurer decision on record.
What we don't know
Undisclosed, unproven, untried: recorded as data.
Nature
- Not measured Harm to nature: The record holds no measurement of harm to nature.
Record
- None on record The BP payments to TNC and Conservation International, and the board seat details, have no source link in the sources reviewed.
- None on record The baseline and counting method behind the 55 million tonne claim are not stated.
- Unclear Whether any credits were sold, and to whom, is not stated.
- None on record Changes to the forest after 2010 are not stated.
Did the harm stop?
Not stated in the sources reviewed.
Who paid?
Not stated in the sources reviewed.
Sources
Voices on record: — Company or project— Government and regulators— Courts✓ Press and investigations— Communities and civil society— Researchers
Press and investigations
- The wrong kind of greenThe Nation (J. Hari) · 2010-03-04
Connected cases
Related matters, and cases linked to this one through the same organisations, with the role each played in both.
- BP Deepwater Horizon: the spill, the court cases and the recovery claims United States · 2010–2031
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Recipient of BP funding
- BP (Company) — here: company; partner in the scheme; donor to TNC; there: Well operator and lease holder; pleaded guilty; paid $20.8bn civil settlement; self-insured
- Bahamas debt-for-nature swap Bahamas · 2024
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Conservation organisation involved in the transaction
- Barbados debt-for-nature swap Barbados · 2022
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Guarantor (US$50m)
- Belize blue bond Belize · 2021–2041
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Lender (via subsidiary)
- Bezos Earth Fund: first grants and SBTi funding United States · 2020–2026
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Recipient of $100m (first round)
- Biomas restoration initiative Brazil · 2022
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Nature NGO; director Sérgio Rial was chairman of Santander Brasil when it co-founded Biomas
- Bloomberg, Steyer and Bezos money shapes coal and nature campaigns United States · 2008–2026
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Environmental group that received Bezos Earth Fund money
- BP “Beyond Petroleum” campaign and carbon footprint calculator United Kingdom · 2000–2025
- BP (Company) — here: company; partner in the scheme; donor to TNC; there: Launched the “Beyond Petroleum” brand and the carbon footprint calculator
- BP acquires majority stake in Finite Carbon, a US forest carbon developer United States · 2020
- BP (Company) — here: company; partner in the scheme; donor to TNC; there: acquirer of a majority stake in Finite Carbon
- BP and Eni do not declare gas flared at Iraq's Rumaila field, citing non-operator status Iraq · 2021–2022
- BP (Company) — here: company; partner in the scheme; donor to TNC; there: Non-operator; does not declare Rumaila gas flaring
- BP's Gulf spill used Corexit; Nalco board had ex-BP and Exxon executives United States · date not stated
- BP (Company) — here: company; partner in the scheme; donor to TNC; there: Company responsible for the spill response and dispersant choice
- COP28 decision promoted carbon capture and left room for transition fuels United Arab Emirates · 2023
- BP (Company) — here: company; partner in the scheme; donor to TNC; there: Member of the Global CCS Institute; three of six executives worked or work here
- Coral reef parametric insurance, Quintana Roo Mexico · 2018–2026
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Co-designer of the cover; author of the July 2026 case study
- Danone, Unilever and BP scaled back sustainability goals between 2021 and 2025 Global · 2021–2025
- BP (Company) — here: company; partner in the scheme; donor to TNC; there: Oil company that cut low-carbon investment in 2025
- El Salvador debt-for-nature swap El Salvador · 2024–2025
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Not named for this transaction; a JPMorgan executive sits on its board
- Gabon debt-for-nature swap Gabon · 2023
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Sponsor of the project
- Kenyan water-tower forest evictions followed a 2018 killing by forest guards Kenya · 2016–2024
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: reported water fund operator
- Mosaic settles US hazardous-waste case over phosphogypsum handling United States · 2015
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Conservation organisation listing Mosaic as a corporate partner
- Nature Conservancy began $10 million partnership with Dow Chemical in 2011 United States · 2007–2021
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: conservation group; cooperation partner
- Nature Conservancy gas drilling on Texas City Prairie Preserve United States · 1995–2014
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Landowner and driller
- Palau National Marine Sanctuary Palau · 2015
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Donor group member; former employer of the Agriculture Minister; Micronesia director named in the bill
- Pará state pre-sold 12 million REDD+ credits; federal prosecutors sue to cancel Brazil · 2023–2026
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Named by the MPF as having a conflict of interest
- Sengwer evictions from Embobut forest and the EU Water Towers programme (Kenya) Kenya · 2014–2024
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Water fund overlapping Embobut
- Seychelles 2016 debt-for-nature swap listed among TNC Nature Bonds Seychelles · 2016
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Runs the Nature Bonds programme that lists the Seychelles pilot
- TNC chief scientist urged conservation groups to partner with companies United States · 2011–2015
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Employer of Kareiva; Dow Chemical partner; subject of the essay
- TNC Hawaii coral reef parametric insurance United States · 2022–2026
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Policyholder
- UK agreed up to £21.7bn over 25 years for two CCS clusters United Kingdom · 2024
- BP (Company) — here: company; partner in the scheme; donor to TNC; there: named as a leading company behind the clusters
- US Senate probes Nature Conservancy land sales to its own trustees United States · 2003
- The Nature Conservancy (NGO) — here: conservation group; set up the scheme with BP; there: Organisation whose land sales were the subject of the inquiry