Who gains from saving nature
Ledger 1 : 33 — For each dollar financing nature-based solutions in 2023, about $33 financed activities harmful to nature. (UNEP)
Cases / Protected area / relocation · Kenya · 2007–2024

World Bank and development bank accountability mechanisms: Embobut (Sengwer), Tata Mundra, Arun III, Jale, Cambodia

Nature's voice · report
No measurement of the harm done to me here is on record.
Did nature suffer? Not measured. Disputed
People
  • About 7,000 people were displaced or listed for relocation.
    Sengwer evicted from the Embobut forest in January 2014 (Inspection Panel context).
  • 1 people died.
    Robert Kirotich, shot by Kenya Forest Service guards on 16 January 2018.
  • 1 people were injured.
    Another man was injured in the 2018 raid.
Not on record
  • The record does not name which of my species, waters, soils or forests were harmed.
What the record lacks: 2 none on record · 7 insufficient · 1 not measured · 4 disputed · 1 unclear See the gaps
Accounts of the harm differ
Does protecting the water towers justify the evictions?
  • Government and regulators Government of Kenya: Describes the evictions as protecting the water towers from illegal farming, logging and charcoal production. Nation (Mwananchi)
  • Communities and civil society Forest Peoples Programme: Reported that a Sengwer man was shot and killed in an EU-funded project. Forest Peoples Programme

Development banks run complaint bodies for people harmed by projects they finance. This record follows five matters, with the most complete account for the 2014 World Bank Inspection Panel finding on the Embobut forest in Kenya and the 2018 killing of a Sengwer herder in an EU-funded forest programme.

15%Complaints to 16 accountability mechanisms that ended in an identifiable commitment
2,270 complaints filed up to 2022 (Accountability Counsel, November 2025). 10% ended with at least one commitment fully implemented.

Status As of April–May 2024 (latest dated event): the Kenya Forest Service carried out a new eviction operation in Embobut; no prosecution for the 2018 killing is recorded; the Sengwer petition is listed as ongoing.

What?
Complaints and findings by development-bank accountability bodies on evictions and harm linked to financed projects, with Embobut (Kenya) as the main case. Bretton Woods Project
Where?
Embobut forest, Cherangany Hills, Kenya; also Mundra (India), Nepal, Jale (Albania), Boeung Kak (Cambodia). Bretton Woods Project
When?
Panel report 22 May 2014; shooting 16 January 2018; programme closed 2020; operation April–May 2024. Bretton Woods Project
Who?
Gained
  • Kenya Forest Service and the Kenyan government — Retained control of the Embobut forest; the 2024 operation removed more than 600 families by the ministry's count. Nation (Mwananchi)
Lost
  • Sengwer community — About 7,000 evicted in 2014; one herder shot dead in 2018; more than 600 families removed in 2024 by the ministry's count. Forest Peoples Programme
  • Boeung Kak residents (Cambodia) — About 4,250 families' eviction linked by the Inspection Panel to the Bank-financed land-titling project.
Harmed
None on record
Why?
The Kenyan government describes the evictions as protecting the water towers; the Panel found the evictions risk had not been identified. Nation (Mwananchi)
How?
Evictions by Kenya Forest Service guards in a forest project financed by the World Bank (2007) and later an EU programme (2016); complaints went to the Inspection Panel. Bretton Woods Project
6 of 6 questions answered from the record

What happened

The record, in order.

Development banks run independent bodies that take complaints from people harmed by projects the banks finance: the World Bank Inspection Panel (set up in 1993), the Compliance Advisor Ombudsman (CAO) for the World Bank's private-sector arms IFC and MIGA, and similar bodies at Asian and African development banks. The banks present these as high standards and independent oversight.

In Kenya, about 7,000 Sengwer were evicted from the Embobut forest in January 2014. In May 2014 the Inspection Panel found that the risk of eviction had been foreseeable but not identified in the forest project the Bank approved in 2007, and that safeguards had not been properly applied. The Bank's president welcomed the finding that the Bank was not linked to the evictions. the sources reviewed give no compensation.

In June 2016 the EU began a €31 million programme with the Kenyan government to protect the 'water tower' forests of the Cherangany Hills and Mount Elgon. On 16 January 2018 Kenya Forest Service guards shot dead Robert Kirotich, a 41-year-old Sengwer herder, in the Embobut forest during an eviction raid. The EU suspended the programme the next day and closed it in 2020. the sources reviewed give no prosecution.

In April and May 2024 the Kenya Forest Service ran a 170-officer operation, 'Imarisha Msitu', in Embobut. The ministry said more than 600 families were removed. The Kenya Forest Service said it had paid 2,874 families KSh 410,000 each in 2013 and that the Sengwer had returned in breach of a court order; the community said it had not received the payment.

At Tata Mundra, India, the IFC's CAO found non-compliance and the sources reviewed give no remedy step by IFC. In Cambodia the Inspection Panel found that a $24 million land-titling project, financed by the Bank, excluded Boeung Kak residents from registration and contributed to the eviction of about 4,250 families; the Bank froze new lending to Cambodia in 2011. The CAO acknowledged a 'remedy gap' in April 2023.

  1. 2007World Bank approves the Natural Resource Management Project in Kenya
  2. 2011World Bank freezes new lending to Cambodia after the Inspection Panel's Boeung Kak finding
  3. 2014January: about 7,000 Sengwer evicted from Embobut forest. 22 May: Inspection Panel report on the Kenya project
  4. 2016June: EU launches €31 million WaTER programme with the Kenyan government
  5. 201816 January: Robert Kirotich shot dead by Kenya Forest Service guards; 17 January: EU suspends the programme
  6. 2020A Kenyan court dismisses the Sengwer case; EU closes the programme; 28 Sengwer homes burned in July
  7. 2021Court of Appeal reportedly orders that people living in the forest that day not be evicted
  8. 202310 April: CAO advisory note acknowledges a 'remedy gap'; February: IFC draft remedy approach criticised for not covering past harms
  9. 2024April–May: Kenya Forest Service operation 'Imarisha Msitu' in Embobut

What was said

Claims, in the words of those who made them.

Where accounts differ

Each party's account, side by side, with its source. The record does not settle these points; it shows them.

Was the World Bank linked to the 2014 Embobut evictions?
International bodies
World Bank Inspection Panel

Found that the risk of eviction had been foreseeable but not identified and that safeguards were not properly applied.

Bretton Woods Project
International bodies
World Bank (president)

Welcomed the finding that the Bank was not linked to the evictions.

Bretton Woods Project
How many people were removed from Embobut in 2024, and had the 2013 payment been made?
Government and regulators
Kenya ministry

More than 600 families removed; a photo caption cited about 200 homes burned.

Nation (Mwananchi)
Government and regulators
Kenya Forest Service

Paid 2,874 families KSh 410,000 each in 2013; the Sengwer violated a court order by returning.

Nation (Mwananchi)
Communities and civil society
Sengwer community

Said it did not receive the payment.

Nation (Mwananchi)
Communities and civil society
Minority Rights Group

Counts more than 800 houses and more than 2,800 families.

Minority Rights Group (summary)
Does protecting the water towers justify the evictions?
Government and regulators
Government of Kenya

Describes the evictions as protecting the water towers from illegal farming, logging and charcoal production.

Nation (Mwananchi)
Communities and civil society
Forest Peoples Programme

Reported that a Sengwer man was shot and killed in an EU-funded project.

Forest Peoples Programme
Do complaint mechanisms deliver remedy?
Company or project
Development banks

Emphasise highest standards and independent oversight.

Communities and civil society
Accountability Counsel

Of 2,270 complaints to 16 mechanisms up to 2022, 15% ended in an identifiable commitment and 10% in at least one commitment fully implemented; a 2024 analysis said the most likely outcome of a complaint was nothing.

International bodies
CAO (IFC/MIGA)

Acknowledged a remedy gap even in cases where non-compliance was found.

Compliance Advisor Ombudsman (IFC/MIGA)

How it looked

What was shown, beside what was recorded.

Shown

  • Development banks emphasise 'highest standards' and independent oversight of their projects.
    Development banks, as described in the sources reviewed
  • The Kenyan government has described the evictions as protecting the water towers from illegal farming, logging and charcoal production.
    Government of Kenya, as described in the sources reviewed

Recorded

  • The Inspection Panel found in 2014 that the risk of eviction had been foreseeable but not identified in the Kenya forest project and that safeguards were not properly applied.
  • Robert Kirotich, 41, was shot dead in the Embobut forest by Kenya Forest Service guards on 16 January 2018; reports say about 40 guards took part.
  • The EU suspended the €31 million programme on 17 January 2018 and closed it in 2020, citing the 'lapsing of a contractual deadline'.
  • Accountability Counsel's November 2025 study of 2,270 complaints to 16 mechanisms found that 15% ended in an identifiable commitment and 10% in at least one commitment fully implemented; retaliation against complainants was widespread.
  • The CAO acknowledged in April 2023 a 'remedy gap': many people remained without remedy even where non-compliance was found.

Who gained

Money that reached nature, beside money that stayed elsewhere.

Reached nature or the ground

Not published
No figure published.

Gained elsewhere

€31m
Programme value as reported; the sources reviewed give no breakdown of what was spent.
EU WaTER programme (Kenya), suspended 2018, closed 2020€31m
Currency: EUR · Window: 2016–2020. All figures cover the same period. * Estimate built from cited figures.

Responses on record

  • World Bank (president) (2014): Welcomed the Inspection Panel's finding that the Bank was not linked to the evictions. the sources reviewed give no compensation. · Bretton Woods Project
  • European Union (2018–2020): Suspended the €31 million WaTER programme on 17 January 2018, announced by its ambassador to Kenya; closed it in 2020 citing the 'lapsing of a contractual deadline'. · REDD-Monitor
  • Kenya Forest Service (May 2024): Said it paid 2,874 families KSh 410,000 each in 2013 and that the Sengwer breached a court order by returning to the forest. · Nation (Mwananchi)
  • Government of Kenya (ministry) (May 2024): Said more than 600 families were removed in the April–May 2024 operation, which it described as protecting the water towers from illegal farming, logging and charcoal production. · Nation (Mwananchi)
  • Compliance Advisor Ombudsman (IFC/MIGA) (April 2023): Acknowledged in an advisory note a 'remedy gap': many people remain without remedy even where non-compliance is found. · Compliance Advisor Ombudsman (IFC/MIGA)

In court and with insurers

Every proceeding and every insurer decision on record.

Lawsuits and rulings

  1. 2013–2014-05-22Claimant won
    Inspection Panel review of the Kenya Natural Resource Management Project
    World Bank Inspection Panel · International court · Requesters to the Inspection Panel → World Bank

    The Panel found that eviction risk was foreseeable but not identified and that safeguards were not properly applied. The Bank's president welcomed the finding that the Bank was not linked to the evictions. the sources reviewed give no compensation. Bretton Woods Project

  2. 2018–Ongoing
    Sengwer petition on the Embobut evictions
    Kenyan courts (court not specified in the sources reviewed) · Civil · Sengwer community → Government of Kenya / Kenya Forest Service

    A court dismissed the Sengwer case in 2020. The Court of Appeal reportedly ordered in 2021 that people living in the forest that day not be evicted. the sources reviewed lists the Sengwer's 2018 petition among ongoing matters. REDD-Monitor (summary)

  3. unknown–unknownClaimant won
    CAO compliance finding on IFC's Tata Mundra investment
    Compliance Advisor Ombudsman (IFC/MIGA) · International court · Mundra fishing community (complainants) → IFC

    The CAO found non-compliance; the sources reviewed give that IFC took no remedy step.

Insurers

No insurer decision on record.

What nature saw

Outcomes measured on the ground, and nature's note.

Nature's report opens this page. Below: further outcomes measured on the ground.

EU programme to protect the water-tower forests
Closed in 2020
€31 million programme launched June 2016; suspended 17 January 2018
Eviction operation in Embobut forest
600+ families
Ministry figure for April–May 2024; Minority Rights Group counts more than 800 houses and 2,800 families

What we don't know

Undisclosed, unproven, untried: recorded as data.

Nature

  • Not measured Harm to nature: The record holds no measurement of harm to nature.
  • Disputed Does protecting the water towers justify the evictions?

Accounts

  • Disputed Was the World Bank linked to the 2014 Embobut evictions?
  • Disputed How many people were removed from Embobut in 2024, and had the 2013 payment been made?
  • Disputed Do complaint mechanisms deliver remedy?

Record

  • Unclear Whether anyone has been prosecuted for the killing of Robert Kirotich: no prosecution found.
  • None on record Compensation to the Sengwer after the 2014 Inspection Panel finding: no record found.
  • Insufficient Reported but not independently verified: that about 70% of the Sengwer evicted in 2014 returned to the forest.
  • Insufficient Reported but not independently verified: that a Nature Conservancy water fund overlapping Embobut allocated KSh 5 million to the Sengwer and KSh 15 million to the Ogiek and Cherangani (August 2023).
  • Insufficient Reported but not independently verified: that the US Supreme Court removed absolute immunity of international organisations in 2019 in the Tata Mundra fishermen's case (Jam v. IFC), that the case was later dismissed for lack of US commercial activity, and that the last application was rejected in 2022.
  • Insufficient Reported but not independently verified: that the World Bank withdrew its financing from the Arun III dam in Nepal in 1995.
  • Insufficient Reported but not independently verified: that after demolitions in Jale, Albania, a coastal project was suspended in 2009, with remedy for nine families designed as legal aid rather than direct payment (nine families, fifteen buildings).
  • Insufficient Reported but not independently verified: that the Asian Development Bank's compliance review of its Cambodia railway project found inadequate compensation in 2014, while management said more than 90% of households received some compensation.
  • Insufficient Reported but not independently verified: that the Inspection Panel had received 120 requests, registered 90 and investigated 34 by September 2017, and that a 2016 report counted 758 complaints to 11 mechanisms in 21 years.
  • None on record The outcome of the Sengwer's 2018 petition: the sources reviewed lists it among ongoing matters.

Did the harm stop?

The EU suspended its programme the day after the shooting and closed it in 2020. Evictions continued in 2024.

Who paid?

Sengwer families bore the evictions: about 7,000 people in 2014 and more than 600 families in 2024 by the ministry's count. the sources reviewed give no compensation after the Panel finding.

Sources

Voices on record: — Company or project— Government and regulators— Courts✓ Press and investigations✓ Communities and civil society— Researchers✓ International bodies

Press and investigations

International bodies

  1. CAO advisory note on remedy: insights on the remedy gap
    Compliance Advisor Ombudsman (IFC/MIGA) · 2023-04-10

Connected cases

Related matters, and cases linked to this one through the same organisations, with the role each played in both.

Places and local terms

Conservancy (Kenya)
In Kenya, land managed by a community or private owners for wildlife alongside grazing, often with outside partners.
Pastoralists
People whose livelihoods depend on moving livestock between grazing lands.

Carbon and conservation finance

REDD+
Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and forest Degradation. A UN framework under which forest projects earn carbon credits for deforestation they say they prevented, measured against a projected baseline.

Bonds and banking

Arranger
The bank that structures and sells a bond or loan deal, usually for a fee.

Law and courts

Land titling
Formal legal recognition of ownership of land.