Who gains from saving nature
Ledger 1 : 33 — For each dollar financing nature-based solutions in 2023, about $33 financed activities harmful to nature. (UNEP)
Cases / Conservation money

Tree planting

47 cases in 44 countries, 1974–2024. Most cases: India (5), Brazil (4), Ethiopia (4), Kenya (4), United States (3).

Carbon credits · Brazil · 2024

Microsoft forestry carbon deals and the Apple Restore Fund

Microsoft contracted tens of millions of tonnes of forestry-based carbon removal from re.green, Rubicon, Chestnut Carbon and Kijani Forestry, while its own emissions rose 29% between 2020 and 2023. Apple's Restore Fund, managed by Climate Asset Management, invests partly in plantings of commercial species such as eucalyptus.

re.green 3 Mt · Chestnut 7 Mt · Rubicon 18 Mt
Forestry carbon removal contracted by Microsoft (as reported)
No court caseNo independent ecological evaluation
Tree planting · Japan · 2024

Felling of 619 old trees begins for Tokyo's Jingu Gaien redevelopment

Felling of 619 old trees began in Tokyo for the Jingu Gaien redevelopment, which was presented as increasing the number of trees. The stake is the loss of mature urban trees against that claim.

Tree planting · Spain · 2024–2025

Spanish region expropriates olive groves for Lopera solar plants

A regional government in Spain declared solar plants in Lopera, Jaén, of public interest and moved to expropriate olive groves from owners who refused to sell. Campaigners put the trees at risk near 100,000, against 13,000 given by the government.

Tree planting · India · 2023–2025

Great Nicobar project compensatory afforestation (India)

About 130 km² of tropical forest on Great Nicobar island was set aside for an airport, port, power plant and city, with the compensatory afforestation planned about 2,400 km away in Haryana. On 20 June 2023 a Haryana village's land was placed under protection, and the state's mining department auctioned a quarter of it the same day.

about 2,400 km
Distance between the forest set aside and the compensatory planting site
Case pending / contested
Tree planting · Uzbekistan · 2023–2024

Over one million unplanted saplings in Uzbekistan reported as planted

In June 2024 Uzbekistan's Prosecutor General's Office reported 541 cases in which more than a million seedlings of the Yashil Makon (Green Space) project were recorded as planted but existed only on paper. In October 2024 the president said more than a million trees had been planted on non-irrigated land or falsely reported.

Carbon credits · Brazil · 2022

Biomas restoration initiative

Six Brazilian and international companies announced Biomas at COP27 in November 2022, a company to restore, conserve and preserve 4 million hectares over 20 years, financed by selling carbon credits. Later project details come from press reports and are unconfirmed.

4 million ha in 20 years
Stated target of a company founded by Vale, Itaú Unibanco, Marfrig, Rabobank, Santander and Suzano
Tree planting · Egypt · 2022–2026

Historic Nile floating houses removed in Cairo; tree felling in 2026 sparks outcry

Historic floating houses on the Nile in Cairo were removed, and in September 2026 The National reported that tree felling in the city had sparked national outcry. The stake is the city's trees and its historic Nile-side homes.

Tree planting · Uzbekistan · 2021–2026

Yashil Makon tree-planting programme in Uzbekistan

The government reported 872 million seedlings planted over four years under Yashil Makon, against an annual plan of 200 million. Prosecutor inspections in 2023, statements by the president in 2024 and 2026 and an Accounts Chamber audit in 2026 recorded seedlings entered in reports but not planted, planted without irrigation, or dried out.

872 million
Seedlings the government reports planted over four years
No court caseKey earnings undisclosed
Tree planting · Mongolia · 2021–2026

Mongolia's One Billion Trees movement: pledges, offset trees and reported survival rates

A presidential decree presented on 4 October 2021 launched a national campaign to plant one billion trees by 2030. Reported totals mix trees planted directly with “offset” trees counted from investment, and reported survival rates differ by source.

83.9 million
Trees reported by the National Forest Agency, May 2025
No court caseNo independent ecological evaluation
Carbon credits · Sahel · 2021–2024

Sahel restoration carbon finance: AFR100 pledges, a projected USD 28bn carbon asset value and 11 registered projects in Great Green Wall countries

AFR100 stated that 33 African countries had committed to restore 129.27 million hectares, with USD 1bn in development finance and USD 481 million in private commitments. A December 2024 WEF and Tree Aid paper projected carbon asset value of up to USD 28bn in Great Green Wall countries, where 11 of Africa's 74 registered nature-based voluntary carbon projects were located.

Up to USD 28bn
Projected carbon asset value, Great Green Wall countries
No court case
Tree planting · Brazil · 2021–2022

Campaigners claim Suzano eucalyptus dried over 130 streams in Brazil

Brazilian pulp company Suzano is a partner in the Biomas restoration venture and an early 1t.org tree pledger. Campaigners claim its eucalyptus monoculture has dried more than 130 streams, and the cited sources do not record a reply from Suzano.

Natural-capital land · United Kingdom · 2020–2025

Scotland's natural-capital land rush

Companies bought estates to plant forests and offset emissions. Estate prices rose about 87% in a year; at one flagship site more than half the young pines died.

+157%
Woodland carbon unit price
No court caseNo independent ecological evaluation
Tree planting · Sweden · 2020–2021

Sveaskog logging of old forest in Luokta-Mávas Sámi reindeer land (Sweden)

Sveaskog, Sweden's state-owned forest company, wanted to fell about 700 hectares in the Luokta-Mávas reindeer grazing area; a Sámi representative said only 200 hectares had been agreed. A 2022 study found that old forest lost to felling does not show up in official forest statistics.

About 700 ha vs 200 ha
Felling Sveaskog wanted vs felling agreed, Luokta-Mávas
Carbon credits · Republic of Congo · 2020–2025

TotalEnergies Batéké acacia carbon project (Congo)

A 40,000-hectare acacia plantation on the Batéké plateau in the Republic of Congo was planned to generate carbon credits for TotalEnergies. Reporting found that farmers lost land, and that the project stopped in May 2025 with about 12.5% of the target planted.

~5,000 ha (12.5%)
Planted against the 40,000 ha target when the project stopped (May 2025)
No court caseNo independent ecological evaluation
Tree planting · Kazakhstan · 2020–2026

Kazakhstan's two-billion-tree programme

A 2020 presidential instruction set a target of planting at least 2 billion trees on forest-fund land by 2025; the programme was extended to 2027. Ministry figures put annual tree survival between 31.2% and 50.5% in 2021–2024, against a launch target of 65%, and a Mazhilis deputy said in 2025 that millions of trees reported as planted in some regions could not be found.

31.2%–50.5%
Survival of planted trees by planting year (Ministry of Ecology)
No court case
Tree planting · Sweden · 2020–2025

Land sales and logging on Sami reindeer pasture in Sweden, NGO reports

Global Forest Coalition reported that 10,400 ha were sold in Sami areas of Sweden, including more than 2,000 ha of reindeer pasture, and that 400 ha of forest were logged in 32 forests. For nature, the stake is forest cover and the grazing land that reindeer herders depend on.

Tree planting · Ethiopia · 2019–2025

Ethiopia: 353 million seedlings in a day

Ethiopia announced that 353,633,660 seedlings were planted in 12 hours in July 2019. The government later put survival above 80%; a study in one district found 39.8%.

83.4% vs 39.8%
Survival: government figure vs one district study
No court caseNo independent ecological evaluation
Tree planting · Mexico · 2019–2022

Sembrando Vida (Sowing Life)

Mexico's tree-planting programme pays farmers a monthly sum to plant trees. A World Resources Institute estimate found it may have contributed to the loss of 72,830 hectares of forest cover in its first year.

72,830 ha
Forest cover loss linked to the programme, first year
No court case
Carbon credits · Netherlands · 2019–2023

Shell nature-based solutions and carbon-neutral driving ads

Shell announced up to $300 million for natural ecosystems and offered customers carbon-neutral driving by offsetting fuel emissions. The Dutch Advertising Code Committee found the carbon-neutral advertising misleading; its rulings are not binding.

up to $300m
Shell's announced investment in natural ecosystems, 2019–2021
No court caseNo independent ecological evaluation
Carbon credits · Russia · 2019–2026

Russian forest-climate projects: RUSAL fire-protection units and Sakhalin larch planting

RUSAL Krasnoyarsk's aerial fire-protection project on 504,986 hectares earned Russian carbon units, and units from it were sold to a UAE fund in October 2024 in the first foreign transaction in Russia's registry. Registry operator, forestry agency and scientists have questioned forest-project quality in general, and one registered project plans to plant larch on bogs on Sakhalin.

1,229,080
RUSAL project units in circulation in the registry
No court caseNo independent ecological evaluation
Tree planting · United States · 2019

Community land trust for 11th Street Bridge Park holds over 250 housing units

A community land trust set up for the 11th Street Bridge Park in Washington, D.C., holds more than 250 housing units, and 131 households bought homes, according to Results for America. The cited sources do not describe the park's effect on the natural environment.

Tree planting · Kenya · 2018–2026

Kenya's 15 billion trees target

Kenya set a target of 15 billion trees and 30% tree cover by 2032, and declared a national tree-planting day in 2023. The same year it lifted a logging ban; an environmental court halted the lifting.

15bn target / 900m+ reported
Target vs reported planting
Court ruling existsNo independent ecological evaluation
Tree planting · Kenya · 2018–2024

Kenya logging ban lifted and eucalyptus felling

Kenya lifted its 2018 logging ban in July 2023 and a court set the decision aside in October 2023. A 2024 report cited six million eucalyptus trees in six months, while the government set a target of 15 billion trees by 2032.

6 million
Eucalyptus trees reported in six months of 2024
Court ruling exists
Tree planting · Uzbekistan · 2018–2026

Afforestation of the dried Aral Sea bed in Uzbekistan

The Government of Uzbekistan states that protective plantings were set up on about 2 million hectares of the dried Aral Sea bed in 2018–2025 to hold down sand, salt and dust. The government releases state no budget and no survival rate; a forestry scientist put sapling survival at 50–70% in wetter years and about 30% in low-rainfall years.

2 million ha
Area the government reports planted on the dried seabed, 2018–2025
No court caseKey earnings undisclosed
Tree planting · Multiple countries · 2017–2020

Record tree-planting claims in Ethiopia, India and Türkiye lack independent checks

Governments in Ethiopia and Türkiye announced planting totals and survival rates that no independent count has confirmed. Tree planting may also be unsuited to savanna land counted in African restoration pledges.

Carbon credits · Pakistan · 2015–2025

Delta Blue Carbon mangrove project (Pakistan)

A 60-year partnership between the Government of Sindh and Indus Delta Capital restores mangroves in the Indus Delta and sells carbon credits. Reported revenue to the province ranges from $14.7 million to about $50 million, and no community share has been published.

Not disclosed
Share of credit revenue reported as reaching communities
No independent ecological evaluationKey earnings undisclosed
Tree planting · Philippines · 2015–2019

State auditors reported 61% survival for Philippine tree planting, 2015-2019

Reviewing 2015-2019 tree planting by the environment department, state auditors reported a 61 per cent survival rate. Whether the planting restored forest is not on record.

Tree planting · Indonesia · 2012–2024

Sinar Mas/APP fires burned 293,065 hectares; replanting was the recorded sanction

Fires in Indonesia from 2012 to 2024 burned 293,065 hectares linked to Sinar Mas/APP and 150,693 hectares linked to RGE/APRIL. The cited sources list replanting as the sanction and do not show how much forest was restored.

Tree planting · Germany / Global · 2011–2024

Plant-for-the-Planet: 13.6 billion trees

A German foundation that took over the UN Environment Programme's tree campaign reported 13.6 billion trees planted. The figure has no independent verification; Die Zeit reported that older UN counts were mixed into it.

13.6bn / none
Trees reported planted vs independently verified
No court caseNo independent ecological evaluation
Tree planting · Brazil · 2010–2024

APRIL pulp suppliers linked to forest loss and Cerrado eucalyptus growth

Suppliers new to pulp company APRIL lost about 80,000 hectares of forest between 2015 and 2024, and eucalyptus plantations in Brazil's Mato Grosso do Sul grew from 378,195 to 1.12 million hectares between 2010 and 2019. At stake for nature is remaining forest and savanna cover in the Cerrado.

Carbon credits · Senegal · 2009–2026

Livelihoods Fund mangrove project (Senegal)

A mangrove-planting project in the Casamance and Sine Saloum deltas planted 10,415 hectares in 2009–2012 and issued almost 500,000 credits, all of which went to its corporate investors. A 2014 verification found almost total loss of tree cover in a quarter of sampled plots.

5.2%
Share of the project budget paid to villagers
Key earnings undisclosed
Agriculture, livestock and food · Mozambique · 2007

Chikweti forestry plantations (Mozambique)

A Dutch pension fund held a majority stake in a fund that planted pine and eucalyptus in Niassa province, Mozambique. A 2010 government review found that 32,000 hectares were occupied without land-use rights.

32,000 ha
Land occupied without DUAT (government review, September 2010)
Tree planting · Sahel (11 countries) · 2007–2026

Great Green Wall: USD 19bn tracked, USD 2.5bn disbursed by March 2023, and a restored area reported at between 1.66 and almost 18 million hectares

The African Union's Great Green Wall initiative has 2030 targets of 100 million hectares restored, 250 MtC sequestered and 10 million green jobs. The UNCCD's Independent Review reported USD 19bn pledged and USD 2.5bn disbursed in March 2023; its 2026 review reported 1.66 million hectares under restoration at 31 December 2025.

USD 2.5bn of USD 19bn
Disbursed against pledged, March 2023
No court caseKey earnings undisclosed
Tree planting · India · 2006–2025

India CAMPA compensatory afforestation fund

India's compensatory afforestation fund collects payments from projects that clear forest land and spends them on planting. Civil-society records document planting on land communities held or claimed, and an official audit found fund money used on consumer goods.

67.5%
Share of CAMPA money approved for 2019-2024 that was spent
Court ruling exists
Tree planting · Sri Lanka / Philippines / Indonesia / India · 2005–2022

Mangrove restoration failures (Sri Lanka, Philippines, Indonesia, Sundarbans)

Mangrove planting programmes in four regions announced targets in hectares or seedlings. Field studies and press reports record low survival at many sites, and in two cases the implementing body's announcement could not be matched with survival data.

1,000-1,200 ha vs 200-220 ha
Sri Lanka after the 2004 tsunami: hectares planted vs hectares with mangrove at survey
Under standard-setter review
Tree planting · Cameroon · 2002

Dutch timber firm Koninklijke Wijma penalised in Cameroon in 2002

Koninklijke Wijma, a timber company based in Kampen, was penalised in January 2002 for felling protected species and small-diameter trees in Cameroon. Greenpeace said it found Wijma-stamped logs outside the company's permit area.

Tree planting · Kenya · 2001–2026

Kenya's two official figures: 8.83% forest cover and 12.13% tree cover

Kenya's Forest Service reports 8.83% forest cover and 12.13% tree cover for 2021, and the constitution's 10% target is tied to tree cover. Satellite data shows more than 19% tree cover loss in the Mau Forest from 2001 to 2022, which the Forest Service disputes.

Tree planting · China · 1998–2014

China's natural forest logging ban and the shift of timber imports

China limited natural-forest logging from 1998 and banned it fully from 2014, while timber imports rose above domestic commercial output. A 2010 study cited in the sources says 74% of China's forest gain over the last five years was offset by displacement abroad.

Protected area / relocation · Costa Rica · 1997

Costa Rica payments for ecosystem services and forest recovery

Since 1997 Costa Rica has paid landowners not to cut forest or to plant trees, and forest cover rose from about 21% in the late 1980s to nearly 60%. An independent study of the early years found no significant effect of the payments on deforestation.

About 21% to about 60%
Forest cover: late 1980s to today
Under standard-setter review
Carbon credits · Uganda · 1990–2009

FACE Foundation Mount Elgon carbon forest (Uganda)

A 1994 agreement covering 25,000 hectares of Mount Elgon in Uganda is listed as a carbon forest project. Reporting links the project area to the eviction of the Benet people.

25,000 ha
Area covered by the 1994 agreement
Displacement reported
Tree planting · Philippines · 1989–1998

FAO data show Philippine old-growth forest was 3.3% of land by 1998

FAO's 1998 assessment put old-growth dipterocarp forest at 984,100 hectares, 3.3% of the country's land area, and found that 57% of industrial log supply came from illegal logging and other substitutes.

Tree planting · Vietnam · 1987–2006

Vietnam's forest recovery and logging displaced abroad

Vietnam restricted logging in its natural forests from 1992 and its forest cover rose. A 2009 study found that wood harvesting equal to 39.1% of the domestic regrowth was displaced abroad, about half of the imports being illegal.

39.1%
Domestic forest regrowth offset by wood harvested abroad, 1987–2006
No court caseNo independent ecological evaluation
Tree planting · United States · 1987–2004

US Northwest federal logging limits and the shift of timber cutting

Federal logging on Pacific Northwest forests fell from 12.7 billion board-feet in 1987 to 1.7 billion in 2002. A 2019 letter by Brian Murray confirms an earlier finding that more than 80% of the blocked volume moved to other North American forests, mainly the US South.

Tree planting · Kenya · 1977–2023

Green Belt Movement and Karura Forest, Kenya

A tree-planting movement founded in Kenya in 1977 campaigned against land grabs in public forests. The cited sources show 477 hectares of Karura Forest allocated to 64 developers in 1994–1999 and continuing tree-cover loss in the Mau Forest.

477 ha / 64 developers
Public forest at Karura allocated to private developers, 1994–1999
Court ruling exists
Tree planting · Chile · 1974–2012

Chile's Decree-Law 701 planting subsidy raised tree cover but cut native forest

A 1974–2012 decree that paid 75 percent of planting costs in Chile was linked to rising tree cover and falling native forest. A 2020 study found no rise in carbon storage and faster biodiversity loss.

Carbon credits · Myanmar · date not stated

Worldview International Foundation mangrove project (Myanmar)

A Myanmar mangrove planting programme registered with Verra reports seedling survival of 86 to 96 percent and an AA rating from BeZero. The cited sources contain no independent audit.

86–96%
Self-reported seedling survival
No independent ecological evaluation
Tree planting · India · 2021

Decades of planting in Himachal Pradesh did not raise average forest cover

A 2021 study found no net canopy gain across 430 plantations in the Indian state, and little direct benefit for local people from decades of planting.

All cases, with filters →