Who gains from saving nature
Ledger 1 : 33 — For each dollar financing nature-based solutions in 2023, about $33 financed activities harmful to nature. (UNEP)
Cases / Law, regulation and treaties · Greece · 2010–2025

Kyparissia Bay (Thines Kyparissias), Greece: construction, roads and beach use at a loggerhead nesting site, CJEU C-504/14 (2016)

Nature's voice · report
On 10 November 2016 the Court of Justice found breaches of the Habitats Directive at my Kyparissia nesting beach, covering about 50 dwellings begun, five new roads, beach bars and light pollution. Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)
Did nature suffer? Yes. Harm is on record. Accounts differ ↓
Recorded
  • My Dunes of Kyparissia site is listed as Natura 2000 site GR2550005, and the Court of Justice found on 10 November 2016 that Greece breached Article 6(2) and Article 12(1)(b) and (d) of the Habitats Directive there. Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)
  • The Court's findings cover tolerated houses at Agiannaki, about 50 dwellings begun between Agiannaki and Elaia, three holiday houses authorised at Vounaki in 2012, five new roads to my Agiannaki beach and the asphalting of existing roads, wild camping, beach bars, beach furniture and a platform near the Messina Mare Hotel, and light pollution. Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)
What the record lacks: 9 none on record · 3 insufficient · 2 disputed See the gaps
Accounts of the harm differ
Whether construction activity at the bay continued

On 10 November 2016 the Court of Justice of the European Union found that Greece had breached Articles 6(2) and 12(1)(b) and (d) of the Habitats Directive at Kyparissia Bay, a Natura 2000 loggerhead nesting beach in Messinia. The Bern Convention file opened in 2010 remained open in October 2026.

About 6,100Loggerhead nests recorded in 2025 (ARCHELON)
5,200 in the 9.5 km core stretch and 900 north of Neda; ARCHELON states this is 74% above the previous 12-year average (22 October 2025).

Status As of October 2026: the Bern Convention file (2010/5) is open; the 2018 decree is in force; no second action before the Court of Justice has been found.

What?
Construction, roads, camping, beach bars, beach furniture and light pollution at a Natura 2000 loggerhead nesting beach led the Commission to take Greece to the Court of Justice, which on 10 November 2016 found breaches of Article 6(2) and Article 12(1)(b) and (d) of the Habitats Directive. Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)
Where?
Kyparissia Bay (Thines Kyparissias), Messinia, Peloponnese, Greece; Natura 2000 site GR2550005 "Dunes of Kyparissia"; the Agiannaki, Elaia, Vounaki and Kalo Nero areas are named in the judgment. Council of Europe, Bern Convention
When?
2010 (Bern complaint) to 2025; judgment of the Court of Justice on 10 November 2016; Presidential Decree of 17 September 2018; Council of State decision 167/2021 (decided 18 June 2020, published 3 February 2021). Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)
Who?
Gained
None on record
Lost
Harmed
Why?
The sources reviewed give no reason for the construction beyond the Court's findings. Greece told the Court that construction activity had "in practice, ceased" after the financial crisis. The developer company that cut the roads is not named. Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)
How?
MEDASSET complained to the Bern Convention in 2010; the Commission sent letters, a formal notice and a reasoned opinion and sued on 11 November 2014; the Court found breaches; Greece designated a Nature Protection Area by decree in 2018, which the Council of State upheld against the Municipality of Zacharo. Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)
6 of 6 questions answered from the record

What happened

The record, in order.

In 2010 MEDASSET complained to the Bern Convention about Kyparissia Bay (Thines Kyparissias) in Messinia, in the Peloponnese. The bay is Natura 2000 site GR2550005, "Dunes of Kyparissia", and a loggerhead (Caretta caretta) nesting beach. The Bern Convention opened file 2010/5 on threats to marine turtles at the site and the Standing Committee adopted Recommendation No. 174 in 2014. The file was listed as open in October 2026. ARCHELON is also named as a complainant.

The European Commission wrote to Greece on 9 August and 19 November 2010, sent a letter of formal notice on 28 October 2011, visited the site on 17 July 2012, issued a reasoned opinion on 1 October 2012 and brought an action before the Court of Justice on 11 November 2014 (Case C-504/14).

On 10 November 2016 the Court (ECLI:EU:C:2016:847) found breaches of Article 6(2) and Article 12(1)(b) and (d) of the Habitats Directive. The findings covered: tolerated houses at Agiannaki; about 50 dwellings begun between Agiannaki and Elaia; three holiday houses authorised at Vounaki in 2012; five new roads to Agiannaki beach and the asphalting of existing roads; wild camping; beach bars; beach furniture and a platform near the Messina Mare Hotel; and light pollution. The Court rejected some of the Commission's claims, including one concerning a road at Kalo Nero and one concerning a permit for four houses at Elaia. It imposed no fine and each party bore its own costs. Greece told the Court (judgment, para. 34) that construction activity had "in practice, ceased" after the financial crisis.

Greece adopted a Presidential Decree of 17 September 2018 (Government Gazette D 391/3.10.2018) designating a Nature Protection Area. The Municipality of Zacharo applied to the Council of State to annul the decree; ARCHELON, MEDASSET Hellas and WWF Hellas intervened. Council of State decision 167/2021, decided on 18 June 2020 and published on 3 February 2021, rejected the application and imposed costs of EUR 460 (State) and EUR 640 (interveners) on the municipality. The Court's judgment in C-849/19 of 17 December 2020, which found that Greece had not set conservation objectives and measures for 239 Sites of Community Importance, is not specific to turtles; the Bern file pages list Thines Kyparissias among the sites concerned.

ARCHELON recorded about 6,100 nests in 2025, of which 5,200 were in the 9.5 km core stretch and 900 north of Neda, which it said was 74% above the previous 12-year average. ARCHELON, citing Casale et al. (2018), says Kyparissia and Laganas together hold over 57% of EU loggerhead nests; the Bern file puts the bay at over 10% of documented Mediterranean nests. ARCHELON states that it covers all Kyparissia monitoring "exclusively with its own resources". As of October 2026 the Bern file was open, the decree was in force and no second action before the Court of Justice had been found.

  1. 2010MEDASSET complains to the Bern Convention (file 2010/5); the Commission writes to Greece on 9 August and 19 November
  2. 2011Commission sends a letter of formal notice (28 October)
  3. 2012Commission visits the site (17 July) and issues a reasoned opinion (1 October); three holiday houses are authorised at Vounaki in 2012
  4. 2014Bern Standing Committee adopts Recommendation No. 174; Commission brings the action in C-504/14 (11 November)
  5. 2016Court of Justice judgment in C-504/14 (10 November): breaches of Habitats Directive Articles 6(2) and 12(1)(b) and (d); no fine
  6. 2018Presidential Decree of 17 September designates a Nature Protection Area (Gazette D 391/3.10.2018)
  7. 2020Council of State decides Municipality of Zacharo's annulment application (18 June); Court of Justice judgment in C-849/19 on 239 Greek Sites of Community Importance (17 December)
  8. 2021Council of State decision 167/2021 published (3 February); application rejected
  9. 2025ARCHELON records about 6,100 nests (22 October) and calls on the State to implement the National Action Plan for the loggerhead

What was said

Claims, in the words of those who made them.

“in practice, ceased”

“exclusively with its own resources”

ARCHELON, on how it covers all Kyparissia monitoring · 22 October 2025 · ARCHELON

Where accounts differ

Each party's account, side by side, with its source. The record does not settle these points; it shows them.

Whether construction activity at the bay continued
Government and regulators
Greece

Told the Court that construction activity had "in practice, ceased" after the financial crisis.

Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)
Courts
Court of Justice of the European Union

Found breaches of Article 6(2) and Article 12(1)(b) and (d) of the Habitats Directive covering houses, dwellings, roads, wild camping, beach bars, beach furniture and light pollution.

Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)
Which of the Commission's complaints were upheld
International bodies
European Commission

Brought claims that included a road at Kalo Nero and a permit for four houses at Elaia, among the other matters in the action.

Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)
Courts
Court of Justice of the European Union

Rejected the claims on the Kalo Nero road and the Elaia permit for four houses and upheld the others listed in its findings.

Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)

How it looked

What was shown, beside what was recorded.

Shown

Recorded

  • The Court of Justice found breaches of Article 6(2) and Article 12(1)(b) and (d) of the Habitats Directive at the site, covering tolerated houses, about 50 dwellings begun, three holiday houses authorised in 2012, five new roads and the asphalting of existing roads, wild camping, beach bars, beach furniture, a platform and light pollution; it rejected the Commission's claims on a road at Kalo Nero and a permit for four houses at Elaia.
  • No fine was imposed in C-504/14 and each party bore its own costs.
  • Bern Convention file 2010/5 (Recommendation No. 174, 2014) was open in October 2026.
  • The Council of State (decision 167/2021) rejected the Municipality of Zacharo's application to annul the 2018 decree and imposed costs of EUR 460 (State) and EUR 640 (interveners) on the municipality.
  • ARCHELON recorded about 6,100 nests in 2025: 5,200 in the 9.5 km core and 900 north of Neda, 74% above the previous 12-year average.
  • Judgment C-849/19 (17 December 2020): Greece had not set conservation objectives and measures for 239 Sites of Community Importance; Greek legislation of 7 May 2020 was too late to count.

Who gained

Money that reached nature, beside money that stayed elsewhere.

Reached nature or the ground

Not published
No figure published.

Gained elsewhere

Not totalled
Court of Justice C-504/14: fine—
No fine; each party bears its own costs.
Council of State 167/2021: costs imposed on the Municipality of Zacharo, in favour of the State—
EUR 460.
Council of State 167/2021: costs imposed on the Municipality of Zacharo, in favour of the interveners—
EUR 640.
Currency: EUR · Window: 2016 to 2021. All figures cover the same period. * Estimate built from cited figures.

Responses on record

  • Greece (Hellenic Republic) (Proceedings in C-504/14, judgment of 10 November 2016): Told the Court of Justice that construction activity at the bay had "in practice, ceased" after the financial crisis. · Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)
  • ARCHELON (22 October 2025): Said it covers all Kyparissia monitoring "exclusively with its own resources" and called on the State to implement the National Action Plan for the loggerhead immediately. · ARCHELON

In court and with insurers

Every proceeding and every insurer decision on record.

Lawsuits and rulings

  1. 2010–Ongoing
    Bern Convention file 2010/5 (Thines Kyparissias), Recommendation No. 174
    Bern Convention Standing Committee (Council of Europe) · International court · MEDASSET (complainant); ARCHELON named as complainant → Greece

    MEDASSET complained to the Bern Convention in 2010. The Standing Committee adopted Recommendation No. 174 in 2014. The file was open in October 2026. Council of Europe, Bern Convention

  2. 2014-11-11–2016-11-10Claimant won
    Commission v Hellenic Republic, Case C-504/14 (ECLI:EU:C:2016:847)
    Court of Justice of the European Union · International court · European Commission → Hellenic Republic

    The Commission sent letters on 9 August and 19 November 2010, a letter of formal notice on 28 October 2011, visited on 17 July 2012, issued a reasoned opinion on 1 October 2012 and sued on 11 November 2014. The Court found breaches of Article 6(2) and Article 12(1)(b) and (d) of the Habitats Directive and rejected some claims (a road at Kalo Nero; a permit for four houses at Elaia). No fine was imposed; each party bore its own costs. Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)

  3. 2020-06-18Defendant won
    Municipality of Zacharo v the State: application to annul the Presidential Decree of 17 September 2018, Council of State decision 167/2021
    Council of State of Greece · Administrative · Municipality of Zacharo → Greek State (ARCHELON, MEDASSET Hellas and WWF Hellas intervening)

    The Council of State rejected the municipality's application to annul the decree designating a Nature Protection Area (Gazette D 391/3.10.2018). The decision, taken on 18 June 2020, was published on 3 February 2021. Costs of EUR 460 (State) and EUR 640 (interveners) were imposed on the municipality. Council of State of Greece (via dsanet.gr)

  4. 2020-12-17Claimant won
    Case C-849/19 (ECLI:EU:C:2020:1047): conservation objectives for 239 Greek Sites of Community Importance
    Court of Justice of the European Union · International court · → Greece

    The Court found that Greece had not set conservation objectives and measures for 239 Sites of Community Importance (Habitats Directive Articles 4(4) and 6(1)); Greek legislation of 7 May 2020 was too late to count. The case is not specific to turtles; the Bern file pages list Thines Kyparissias among the sites. Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex)

Insurers

No insurer decision on record.

What nature saw

Outcomes measured on the ground, and nature's note.

Nature's report opens this page. Below: further outcomes measured on the ground.

Nests recorded, 2025
About 6,100
5,200 in the 9.5 km core and 900 north of Neda; 74% above the previous 12-year average (ARCHELON, 22 October 2025)
Share of EU loggerhead nests (Kyparissia plus Laganas)
Over 57%
ARCHELON, citing Casale et al. (2018)
Share of documented Mediterranean nests
Over 10%
Bern Convention file 2010/5
Court findings
Breaches of Habitats Directive Arts 6(2), 12(1)(b) and (d)
Court of Justice, C-504/14, 10 November 2016

What we don't know

Undisclosed, unproven, untried: recorded as data.

Nature

  • Disputed Whether construction activity at the bay continued

Money

  • None on record Court of Justice C-504/14: fine — No fine; each party bears its own costs.
  • None on record Council of State 167/2021: costs imposed on the Municipality of Zacharo, in favour of the State — EUR 460.
  • None on record Council of State 167/2021: costs imposed on the Municipality of Zacharo, in favour of the interveners — EUR 640.

Accounts

  • Disputed Which of the Commission's complaints were upheld

Record

  • None on record None on record: a fine against Greece in C-504/14; the Court imposed none and each party bore its own costs.
  • None on record Not on record: whether the Presidential Decree of 17 September 2018 is adequate to protect the site.
  • Insufficient Unconfirmed: an NGO survey of houses built after 2018 at Agiannakis and Vounaki.
  • None on record Not on record: whether the road network addressed in the judgment has been removed; a report on the point could not be verified.
  • Insufficient Unconfirmed: a 2025 Council of State ruling rejecting a developer's request to reopen the question of the five roads, reported by Argophilia on 31 August 2025; the decision number was not found.
  • Insufficient Unconfirmed: a developer plot of 25 ha with plans for nearly 50 building permits, reported by Argophilia.
  • None on record Not named in the sources reviewed: the developer company that cut the roads.
  • None on record None on record: a second action before the Court of Justice concerning the site, as of October 2026.
  • None on record No source on record for: a Council of State opinion 32/2015 of 8 April 2015 concerning the site.

Did the harm stop?

The Court recorded Greece's statement that construction activity had in practice ceased after the financial crisis. The 2018 decree designating a Nature Protection Area is in force; whether it is adequate and whether the roads addressed in the judgment were removed is not on record. The Bern file remained open in October 2026.

Who paid?

The Court of Justice imposed no fine and each party bore its own costs (2016). The Council of State imposed costs of EUR 460 (State) and EUR 640 (interveners) on the Municipality of Zacharo (decision 167/2021). ARCHELON states that it covers all Kyparissia monitoring "exclusively with its own resources".

Sources

Voices on record: — Company or project— Government and regulators✓ Courts✓ Press and investigations✓ Communities and civil society— Researchers✓ International bodies

Courts

  1. Council of State decision 167/2021 (published text on dsanet.gr)
    Council of State of Greece (via dsanet.gr) · 2021-02-03
  2. Judgment of the Court of 17 December 2020, Case C-849/19 (ECLI:EU:C:2020:1047)
    Court of Justice of the European Union (EUR-Lex) · 2020-12-17

International bodies

Connected cases

Related matters, and cases linked to this one through the same organisations, with the role each played in both.

Science and environment

Hectare (ha)
A unit of area equal to 10,000 square metres, about 2.5 acres. 100 hectares make one square kilometre.
Protected area / relocation · Law, regulation and treaties · Burning: incineration, open burning, flaring, fires · Russia · 2018–2024
Tukolon reserve sanitary logging conviction in Irkutsk Oblast
Same type: Protected area / relocation, Law, regulation and treatiesSame regionCourt: won by claimant
Law, regulation and treaties · Finance, funds and markets · Protected area / relocation · Ukraine · 2018–2025
Carpathian beech, IKEA's supply chain and FSC certification: Earthsight's 2020 findings and the responses
Same type: Law, regulation and treaties, Protected area / relocationSame regionCourt: ongoing
Law, regulation and treaties · Protected area / relocation · United States · 2025–2026
US Endangered Species Act rollbacks 2025–2026 (God Squad Gulf exemption, critical habitat rules)
Same type: Law, regulation and treaties, Protected area / relocationCourt: ongoingHarm to nature disputed
Law, regulation and treaties · Protected area / relocation · Russia · 2001–2023
Hardwood logging in the Russian Far East and exports to China
Same type: Law, regulation and treaties, Protected area / relocationSame regionHarm to nature disputed
Law, regulation and treaties · Protected area / relocation · Russia · 2020–2026
Baikal Natural Territory: expertise exemptions and clear-cutting rules
Same type: Law, regulation and treaties, Protected area / relocationSame regionHarm to nature disputed
Mining · Finance, funds and markets · Law, regulation and treaties · Protected area / relocation · Venezuela · 2008–2026
Las Cristinas gold project: 2008 permit denial in the Imataca reserve, Crystallex ICSID award and court-ordered sale of CITGO's parent
Same type: Law, regulation and treaties, Protected area / relocationCourt: won by claimant, ongoingHarm to nature disputed