Rigel scuttling (Calabria)
- The record does not name which of my species, waters, soils or forests were harmed.
- Government and regulators Reggio Calabria prosecutors: Investigated a suspicion that the ship carried toxic or radioactive waste; the inquiry was closed because the wreck was never found. Il Post
- Courts La Spezia court: Accepted that the sinking was deliberate and an insurance fraud; the trial did not establish the real cargo and waste was never charged. Il Post
The cargo ship Rigel sank off Calabria in 1987 after sailing with a declared cargo of marble. A La Spezia court accepted that the sinking was deliberate and an insurance fraud; the real cargo was never established and a suspicion of toxic or radioactive waste was never tested because the wreck was not found.
Year of judgment, defendants and sentences not found.
Status As of September 2024: La Spezia judgment accepted deliberate sinking and insurance fraud; the waste inquiry was closed because the wreck was never found.
- The insurer (Lloyd's of London, per L'Unità) — Target of the fraud charge L'Unità (archive)
What happened
The Rigel, a cargo ship owned by Mayfair Shipping Ltd (Valletta), sailed from Marina di Carrara declaring a cargo of marble granulate, blocks and tiles for Limassol. On 21 September 1987 it sank about 20 nautical miles south-east of Capo Spartivento, Calabria, without sending a distress call. A Yugoslav ship carried the crew to Tunis.
A final judgment of the La Spezia court accepted that the sinking was deliberate and an insurance fraud. The charges included criminal association and fraud against the insurer. A 2009 article in L'Unità said the owner was convicted of fraud against the insurance (the Lloyd's of London).
Reggio Calabria prosecutors investigated a suspicion that the ship carried toxic or radioactive waste. That inquiry was closed because the wreck was never found. The La Spezia trial did not establish the real cargo, and waste was never charged.
- 1987Rigel sails from Marina di Carrara declaring marble cargo for Limassol; sinks on 21 September about 20 nautical miles south-east of Capo Spartivento with no distress call; crew taken to Tunis by a Yugoslav ship
- 2009L'Unità (28 September) reports the owner was convicted of fraud against the insurance (Lloyd's of London)
- 2024Il Post (25 September) reports the La Spezia judgment and the closed waste inquiry
What was said
Where accounts differ
Each party's account, side by side, with its source. The record does not settle these points; it shows them.
Investigated a suspicion that the ship carried toxic or radioactive waste; the inquiry was closed because the wreck was never found.
Il PostAccepted that the sinking was deliberate and an insurance fraud; the trial did not establish the real cargo and waste was never charged.
Il PostHow it looked
Shown
- A cargo of marble granulate, blocks and tiles bound for LimassolDeclared cargo, as recorded in Il Post · Il Post
Recorded
- A final judgment of the La Spezia court accepted that the sinking was deliberate and an insurance fraud; charges included criminal association and fraud against the insurer
- The trial did not establish the real cargo; waste was never charged
- The Reggio Calabria inquiry into suspected toxic or radioactive waste was closed because the wreck was never found
In court and with insurers
Lawsuits and rulings
- Claimant wonLa Spezia criminal proceedings over the sinking of the RigelLa Spezia court · Criminal · Prosecution (charges: criminal association and fraud against the insurer) → Rigel's owner side (names not found)
A final judgment accepted that the sinking was deliberate and an insurance fraud. The trial did not establish the real cargo, and waste was never charged. L'Unità (2009) said the owner was convicted of fraud against the insurance (Lloyd's of London). No judgment year, sentences or amounts found. Il Post
- No defendant leftReggio Calabria inquiry into suspected toxic or radioactive waste aboard the RigelReggio Calabria prosecutors · Criminal · Reggio Calabria prosecutors → None charged
Prosecutors investigated suspected toxic or radioactive waste. The inquiry was closed because the wreck was never found. It remains a suspicion, not a finding. Il Post
Insurers
- 1987No policy foundLloyd's of London → Mayfair Shipping Ltd (owner)Stated reason: Court accepted the sinking was deliberate and an insurance fraud
The charges included fraud against the insurer, described in L'Unità as Lloyd's of London. Whether the hull claim was paid was not verified. L'Unità (archive)
What nature saw
Nature's report opens this page. Below: further outcomes measured on the ground.
What we don't know
Nature
- Not measured Harm to nature: No independent ecological evaluation is on record.
- Disputed Was the Rigel carrying marble, or waste?
Insurers
- Unclear Lloyd's of London: no decision on record.
Record
- None on record The real cargo: the La Spezia trial did not establish it, and waste was never charged.
- None on record The suspicion of toxic or radioactive waste: the inquiry was closed because the wreck was never found; it remains a suspicion, not a finding.
- Insufficient Reported but not independently verified: one parliamentary hearing reportedly says Lloyd's paid the hull claim.
Did the harm stop?
No harm to nature is recorded; the wreck was never found and no waste was established.
Who paid?
Not determined: the record gives no payment figure, and the hull claim payment was not verified.
Sources
Press and investigations
- Navi a perdere: naufragi e rifiuti tossici in CalabriaIl Post · 2024-09-25
- L'Unità, 28 September 2009, p. 10L'Unità (archive) · 2009-09-28
Connected cases
- BP Deepwater Horizon: the spill, the court cases and the recovery claims United States · 2010–2031
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Insurer named as defrauded in L'Unità; there: Excess insurers on Transocean's liability programme; market loss estimate $300–600m
- Exxon Valdez: the spill, insurance and court cases United States · 1989–2015
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Insurer named as defrauded in L'Unità; there: Lead of 150+ excess insurers; refused cover, paid $780m after suit
- Insurers of the Carmichael coal mine Australia · 2015–2025
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Insurer named as defrauded in L'Unità; there: Market whose members insured the mine from 2019
- Lead paint public nuisance insurance (Santa Clara) United States · 2000–2024
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Insurer named as defrauded in L'Unità; there: Insurers (Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's) in the ConAgra and NL Industries coverage cases
- Love Canal (New York) United States · 1980–1995
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Insurer named as defrauded in L'Unità; there: Primary insurer; plaintiff in coverage actions
- Net-Zero Insurance Alliance collapse and insurers’ fossil underwriting Global · 2021–2025
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Insurer named as defrauded in L'Unità; there: Insurance market; left NZIA 26 May 2023
- Prestige Spain · 2002–2026
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Insurer named as defrauded in L'Unità; there: Lead hull insurer
- Record cites CIA file on Onassis for 1954 whaling off Peru Peru · 1954–1956
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Insurer named as defrauded in L'Unità; there: reported insurer of the whaling fine (not verified)
- Salem tanker Senegal (offshore) · 1979–1985
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Insurer named as defrauded in L'Unità; there: Cargo underwriters at Lloyd's (defendant Gibbs)
- Trans Mountain pipeline insurers (Canada) Canada · 2018–2024
- Lloyd's of London (Insurer) — here: Insurer named as defrauded in L'Unità; there: Insurance market; syndicates on the 2019–20 policy