Who gains from saving nature
Ledger 1 : 33 — For each dollar financing nature-based solutions in 2023, about $33 financed activities harmful to nature. (UNEP)
Cases / Mining / tailings dam · Indonesia · 2020–2026

IMIP nickel waste landslides and Obi island (Indonesia)

Nature's voice · report
No measurement of the harm done to me here is on record.
Did nature suffer? Not measured. Disputed
People
  • 3 people died.
    22 March 2025 collapse at the QMB waste site; four workers buried, three died.
  • 1 people died.
    February 2026 landslide at the same site.
  • Official count 13 people died.
    24 December 2023 furnace explosion at ITSS; later reports gave 20 to 21.
  • 53 people died.
    Deaths recorded in nickel industrial areas in 2015–2022 (Mongabay Indonesia).
What the record lacks: 4 none on record · 5 insufficient · 1 not measured · 6 disputed · 4 unclear See the gaps
Accounts of the harm differ
Is the water at Kawasi, Obi Island, safe to drink?
  • Press and investigations OCCRP, Gecko Project, The Guardian and Deutsche Welle: Leaked company documents showed chromium-6 above Indonesia's 50 ppb limit: 128 ppb in February 2022, 173 ppb in February 2023, and every one of 30 days tested in August 2022. No interviewed villager recalled receiving a warning.
  • Company or project Harita: Its own tests measured 5 to 40 ppb and the water is drinkable.

Nickel-waste storage at the Indonesia Morowali Industrial Park collapsed in March 2025, killing three subcontract workers, and a further landslide killed one worker in February 2026. On Obi Island, residents of Kawasi village and an OCCRP-led investigation reported chromium-6 readings above Indonesia's drinking-water limit near a nickel smelter; the operator disputes the findings.

4Workers killed in IMIP waste-storage landslides, March 2025 and February 2026
Three on 22 March 2025 and one in February 2026. Walhi Central Sulawesi counted eight waste-management worker deaths at IMIP in total.

Status As of March 2026: no fine or revocation of environmental approval recorded after the two fatal waste landslides at IMIP; as of October 2026 the IRMA audit results for Harita Nickel on Obi were unpublished.

What?
Nickel-waste storage failures at the Indonesia Morowali Industrial Park in March 2025 and February 2026, and contested chromium-6 readings and sago loss at Kawasi village on Obi Island. Mongabay Indonesia
Where?
IMIP, Morowali, Central Sulawesi (Labota village and the km 8 waste site); Kawasi village, Obi Island, North Maluku. Mongabay Indonesia
When?
2020–2026; main events 16 and 22 March 2025, February 2026 and, on Obi, readings from February 2022 and February 2023.
Who?
Gained
  • Tsingshan Holding Group — Described in the sources reviewed as majority owner of IMIP; the ITSS furnace that exploded in December 2023 is linked to it.
  • Zhejiang Huayou Cobalt — Investor in Huayou Nickel Cobalt, one of the operators at the IMIP km 8 waste site, which makes a semi-finished nickel product for batteries.
  • Harita Group — Operator of the nickel mine and smelters at Kawasi, Obi Island. Mongabay Indonesia
  • Indonesian government — Nickel exports reported to have grown from about USD 6 billion to about USD 30 billion; about USD 30 billion in 2022.
Lost
  • Subcontract workers at IMIP — Three died on 22 March 2025 and one in February 2026; Walhi Central Sulawesi counted eight waste-management deaths at the park. Mongabay Indonesia
Harmed
  • Labota village residents — 341 families, 1,092 people, were affected by the 16 March 2025 mud flow. Mongabay Indonesia
  • Kawasi villagers — Chromium-6 readings above the national limit in the water source, according to leaked company documents; sago area and producers fell. Mongabay Indonesia
Why?
Indonesia banned raw nickel ore exports in 2020 to process nickel at home. Battery-grade nickel is made by high-pressure acid leaching, which leaves large volumes of waste; after the government declined to permit deep-sea disposal in 2021, the waste was stored on land.
How?
Waste sludge from acid leaching was stored in land-based facilities that failed in heavy rain (March 2025) and again in February 2026; the company and park cited rain and soft ground, a union cited a filled pond and an earlier slide. Earthworks
6 of 6 questions answered from the record

What happened

The record, in order.

The Indonesia Morowali Industrial Park (IMIP) in Morowali, Central Sulawesi, processes nickel. Indonesia banned exports of raw nickel ore in 2020, and the government said processing nickel at home would make the country a centre of the electric-vehicle battery supply chain. At kilometre 8 of the park, PT QMB New Energy Materials and Huayou Nickel Cobalt operate a site that produces mixed hydroxide precipitate (MHP), a semi-finished nickel product used for electric-vehicle batteries. The process used, high-pressure acid leaching, dissolves low-grade ore in sulphuric acid under heat and pressure and leaves large volumes of waste sludge. Earthworks put the waste at about 120 tonnes per tonne of nickel; a union leader put it at about 10 tonnes.

In 2020 four companies applied for permission to dispose of this waste by pipeline in the deep sea. In 2021 the government announced it would not grant such permits, without issuing a written ban, and the companies began storing the waste on land. On 16 March 2025, in heavy rain, muddy water containing heavy metals flowed from the waste facility of PT Huayue Nickel Cobalt into the Bahodopi River and Labota village. Mongabay Indonesia reported that 341 families, 1,092 people, were affected. On 22 March 2025, shortly after midnight, soil slid at the QMB waste site. Four workers of a subcontractor were buried and three died. The company's first statement attributed the event to continuous rain and reported two victims found and one worker missing. A workers' union said the facility stood on a filled pond and that satellite images from January 2025 showed an earlier slide at the same facility.

In February 2026 another landslide at the same site killed one worker. Mongabay Indonesia reported that IMIP produced 11.5 million tonnes of waste a year and that 47 million tonnes were expected in 2026. A park spokesperson pointed to soft ground beneath the site. Environment Minister Hanif Faisol Nurofiq said the company had caused deaths twice and promised legal and criminal action and revocation of its environmental approval. As of March 2026 no fine or revocation had been recorded. Walhi Central Sulawesi counted eight waste-management worker deaths at IMIP. Mongabay Indonesia also reported 53 deaths in Indonesian nickel industrial areas between 2015 and 2022, and 21 deaths in a furnace explosion at the park on 24 December 2023.

The 24 December 2023 explosion occurred at a furnace of PT Indonesia Tsingshan Stainless Steel (ITSS), which is linked to Tsingshan Holding Group, described in the sources reviewed as IMIP's majority owner. The official count was 13 dead; later reports gave 20 to 21. The first explanation referred to liquid left at the bottom of the furnace. No penalty or prosecution was found in the sources reviewed.

On Obi Island in North Maluku, Kawasi village lies directly behind the nickel mine and smelters of the Harita Group, with the industrial area less than 100 metres from the back of some houses, according to Mongabay Indonesia. An investigation published in April 2025 by OCCRP, the Gecko Project, The Guardian and Deutsche Welle, based on leaked company documents, reported that chromium-6 in the village's drinking-water source repeatedly exceeded Indonesia's limit of 50 parts per billion, with readings of 128 ppb in February 2022 and 173 ppb in February 2023, and that all 30 days tested in August 2022 exceeded the limit. Harita denies the findings, says its own tests measured 5 to 40 ppb and says the water is drinkable. Mongabay Indonesia reported in April 2026, citing district agriculture office data, that sago area in the district fell from 297 hectares in 2023 to 127 hectares in 2025 and the number of sago producers from 284 to 100. Harita Nickel became the first Indonesian mine to enter an audit by the Initiative for Responsible Mining Assurance (IRMA) in October 2024; it chose an optional corrective-action period of up to 12 months, during which results are not published.

  1. 2020Indonesia bans export of raw nickel ore; four companies apply for permission to dispose of HPAL waste in the deep sea
  2. 2021Government announces it will not grant deep-sea waste permits, without a written ban; waste is stored on land
  3. 202324 December: furnace explosion at the ITSS plant in IMIP; official count 13 dead, later reports up to 21
  4. 2024October: Harita Nickel (Obi) enters an IRMA audit
  5. 2025January: union cites satellite images of an earlier slide at the QMB waste site. 16 March: mud flow into Bahodopi River and Labota. 22 March: QMB waste-site collapse, three workers die. April: OCCRP-led investigation on chromium-6 at Kawasi. June: Environment Ministry findings at IMIP reported (unverified figures)
  6. 2026February: a further landslide kills one worker. March: no fine or revocation recorded. April: Mongabay reports sago loss on Obi. July and October: IRMA audit of Harita Nickel still without published results

What was said

Claims, in the words of those who made them.

Where accounts differ

Each party's account, side by side, with its source. The record does not settle these points; it shows them.

What caused the waste-site collapses at IMIP?
Company or project
PT QMB New Energy Materials

Continuous rain caused flooding and a landslide (initial statement, March 2025).

Mongabay Indonesia
Company or project
IMIP park spokesperson

Soft ground beneath the site (February 2026).

Mongabay Indonesia
Communities and civil society
Workers' union

The facility was built on a filled pond, and January 2025 satellite images showed an earlier slide at the same facility.

Earthworks
Government and regulators
Environment Minister Hanif Faisol Nurofiq

The company caused deaths twice; legal and criminal action and revocation of the environmental approval promised, none recorded by March 2026.

Mongabay Indonesia
How much waste does battery-grade nickel leave per tonne?
Communities and civil society
Earthworks

About 120 tonnes of waste per tonne of nickel.

Earthworks
Communities and civil society
A union leader

About 10 tonnes of waste per tonne of nickel.

How many people died in the 24 December 2023 furnace explosion?
Government and regulators
Official count

13 dead.

Press and investigations
Mongabay Indonesia and later reports

21 dead (reports range from 20 to 21).

Mongabay Indonesia
Is the water at Kawasi, Obi Island, safe to drink?
Press and investigations
OCCRP, Gecko Project, The Guardian and Deutsche Welle

Leaked company documents showed chromium-6 above Indonesia's 50 ppb limit: 128 ppb in February 2022, 173 ppb in February 2023, and every one of 30 days tested in August 2022. No interviewed villager recalled receiving a warning.

Company or project
Harita

Its own tests measured 5 to 40 ppb and the water is drinkable.

Was land for the Obi relocation ‘eco-village’ taken with consent?
Press and investigations
Mongabay Indonesia

The eco-village, about 5 km inland, was built on cut and filled sago gardens; villagers said some plots were taken on Sundays or at night without the owners knowing.

Mongabay Indonesia
Company or project
Harita's sustainability manager

Land use followed free, prior and informed consent and was examined in the IRMA audit.

Mongabay Indonesia
Is Indonesian battery nickel ‘low-carbon’?
Government and regulators
Indonesian government and industrial parks

Nickel processed at home for the battery supply chain, presented as low-carbon.

Researchers
CREA

Coal-based producers emit 57–70 tonnes of CO2 per tonne of nickel against a proposed 20-tonne low-carbon threshold; 83% of 2025 output went to stainless steel and 17% to batteries.

Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air (CREA)

How it looked

What was shown, beside what was recorded.

Shown

  • Nickel processed at home to make Indonesia a centre of the electric-vehicle battery supply chain (‘hilirisasi’, downstream processing)
    Indonesian government
  • Nickel presented as ‘low-carbon battery nickel’
    Indonesian state and Chinese-capital industrial parks
  • Continuous rain caused flooding and a landslide (initial statement after the 22 March 2025 collapse)
    PT QMB New Energy Materials · Mongabay Indonesia
  • Soft ground beneath the site (February 2026 landslide)
    IMIP park spokesperson · Mongabay Indonesia
  • A company executive raised a glass of water at the Kawasi water source before the press in April 2023; photographs do not show whether he drank it
    A Harita executive, as reported by OCCRP and partners
  • Land use for the relocation ‘eco-village’ followed free, prior and informed consent and was examined in the IRMA audit
    Harita's sustainability manager · Mongabay Indonesia

Recorded

  • 16 March 2025: mud flow from PT Huayue Nickel Cobalt's waste facility into the Bahodopi River and Labota village; 341 families, 1,092 people affected
  • 22 March 2025: collapse at the QMB waste site; four subcontract workers buried, three died
  • A workers' union said the facility stood on a filled pond; January 2025 satellite images showed an earlier slide at the same facility
  • February 2026: a further landslide at the same site killed one worker; IMIP waste output 11.5 million tonnes a year, 47 million expected in 2026
  • As of March 2026 no fine or revocation of environmental approval recorded after the two fatal landslides
  • Mongabay Indonesia reported 53 deaths in nickel industrial areas in 2015–2022 and 21 deaths in the December 2023 furnace explosion
  • 24 December 2023: furnace explosion at the ITSS plant in the Morowali park, reported by Tempo; the official count was 13 dead, later reports 20–21
  • Kawasi water source: chromium-6 128 ppb (February 2022) and 173 ppb (February 2023) against a 50 ppb limit, per leaked company documents reviewed by OCCRP and partners
  • Sago area in the district fell from 297 ha (2023) to 127 ha (2025); sago producers from 284 to 100
  • CREA: coal-based Indonesian nickel producers emit 57–70 tonnes of CO2 per tonne of nickel against a proposed low-carbon threshold of 20 tonnes; captive coal capacity reached 19.3 GW in July 2025

Who gained

Money that reached nature, beside money that stayed elsewhere.

Reached nature or the ground

Not published
No figure published.

Gained elsewhere

Not totalled
Currency: USD · Window: . All figures cover the same period. * Estimate built from cited figures.

Responses on record

  • pt-qmb (March 2025): Its first statement after the 22 March 2025 collapse said continuous rain caused flooding and a landslide, reported two victims found and one worker missing (as summarised by BHRRC). · Mongabay Indonesia
  • pt-imip (February 2026): A park spokesperson pointed to soft ground beneath the site after the February 2026 landslide. · Mongabay Indonesia
  • indonesia-klh (March 2026): Environment Minister Hanif Faisol Nurofiq said the company had caused deaths twice and promised legal and criminal action and revocation of its environmental approval; no fine or revocation was recorded as of March 2026. · Mongabay Indonesia
  • harita (April 2025 and April 2026): Denies the chromium-6 findings, says its own tests measured 5 to 40 ppb and that the water is drinkable; its sustainability manager wrote that land use for the relocation village followed free, prior and informed consent and was examined in the IRMA audit. · Mongabay Indonesia
  • tsingshan (December 2023): The initial explanation of the 24 December 2023 explosion referred to liquid left at the bottom of the furnace.

In court and with insurers

Every proceeding and every insurer decision on record.

Lawsuits and rulings

  1. Outcome not on record
    Ministry of Environment response to the fatal IMIP waste landslides
    Ministry of Environment (KLH) · Administrative · Ministry of Environment → Operator of the IMIP waste site (PT QMB New Energy Materials in the March 2025 collapse)

    The environment minister said the company had caused deaths twice and promised legal and criminal action and revocation of its environmental approval. As of March 2026 no fine or revocation had been recorded. Mongabay Indonesia

  2. 2022-11Ongoing
    EU v Indonesia: export ban on raw nickel ore (WTO)
    WTO dispute settlement · International court · European Union → Indonesia

    A WTO panel found the ban inconsistent with WTO rules in November 2022. Indonesia appealed into a gap left by the non-functioning Appellate Body, so the ruling was not final. This concerns the export ban, not the waste or water matters. The Jakarta Post

Insurers

No insurer decision on record.

What nature saw

Outcomes measured on the ground, and nature's note.

Nature's report opens this page. Below: further outcomes measured on the ground.

People affected by the Labota mud flow
1,092
341 families, 16 March 2025 (Mongabay Indonesia)
Chromium-6 at the Kawasi water source
128–173 ppb
February 2022 and February 2023, against Indonesia's 50 ppb limit; Harita reports 5–40 ppb in its own tests
Sago area on Obi
297 → 127 ha
2023 to 2025, district agriculture office data via Mongabay Indonesia
Annual IMIP waste output
11.5 → 47 Mt
Current output and the volume expected in 2026 (Mongabay Indonesia)

What we don't know

Undisclosed, unproven, untried: recorded as data.

Nature

  • Not measured Harm to nature: The record holds no measurement of harm to nature.
  • Disputed Is the water at Kawasi, Obi Island, safe to drink?

Court

  • Unclear Ministry of Environment response to the fatal IMIP waste landslides: outcome not on record.

Figures

  • Insufficient Waste unpermitted mt: Environment Ministry finding at IMIP, June 2025;.
  • Insufficient Area (ha): Structures outside the environmental impact assessment at IMIP, June 2025;.

Accounts

  • Disputed What caused the waste-site collapses at IMIP?
  • Disputed How much waste does battery-grade nickel leave per tonne?
  • Disputed How many people died in the 24 December 2023 furnace explosion?
  • Disputed Was land for the Obi relocation ‘eco-village’ taken with consent?
  • Disputed Is Indonesian battery nickel ‘low-carbon’?

Record

  • Unclear Whether any sanction was imposed on the operators after the March 2025 and February 2026 landslides: none recorded as of March 2026.
  • None on record No penalty or prosecution was found for the December 2023 furnace explosion.
  • None on record Death toll of the December 2023 explosion: the official count was 13; later reports gave 20 to 21.
  • None on record Waste volume per tonne of nickel: Earthworks gives about 120 tonnes, a union leader about 10 tonnes.
  • Unclear Whether sanctions for the Environment Ministry's findings at IMIP were applied: unclear in the sources.
  • Insufficient Reported but not independently verified: the Environment Ministry's June 2025 inspection findings at IMIP (structures of more than 1,800 hectares outside the environmental impact assessment, more than 12 million tonnes of unpermitted nickel slag and waste, and 24 emission sources without continuous monitoring). The figures come of the ministry statement.
  • Insufficient Reported but not independently verified: a separate account that some IMIP facilities were missing from the environmental impact assessment (AMDAL) and that a 179-hectare area next to the park was cleared.
  • Insufficient Reported but not independently verified: Rainforest Rescue (2025) reported boron, chromium(VI) and nickel leaking into groundwater and over-full waste dams; the research note places this on Obi Island, while the report's title refers to Morowali.
  • None on record IRMA audit results for Harita Nickel on Obi remained unpublished in October 2026 because the company chose the corrective-action period.
  • Unclear No ruling or court case on the sago land taken for the relocation ‘eco-village’ was found.

Did the harm stop?

Not recorded as stopped. As of March 2026 no fine or revocation of environmental approval had been recorded after the two fatal landslides, and annual waste output was expected to rise from 11.5 to 47 million tonnes in 2026.

Who paid?

Subcontract workers (four died in the two recorded landslides), residents of Labota (341 families affected by the March 2025 mud flow) and villagers of Kawasi, according to the sources cited.

Sources

Voices on record: — Company or project✓ Government and regulators— Courts✓ Press and investigations✓ Communities and civil society— Researchers

Connected cases

Related matters, and cases linked to this one through the same organisations, with the role each played in both.

Science and environment

Groundwater
Water held underground in soil and rock, drawn through wells.
Hectare (ha)
A unit of area equal to 10,000 square metres, about 2.5 acres. 100 hectares make one square kilometre.

Law and courts

Prior consultation
The right of indigenous peoples, under ILO Convention 169 and national laws, to be consulted before measures that affect their lands are adopted.

Insurance

Captive insurer, self-insurance
A company covering its own risks, either directly or through an insurance company it owns.

Carbon and conservation finance

Standard-setter and registry
An organisation that writes the rules for carbon credits, approves projects, and records when credits are issued and retired. Such bodies typically charge fees per credit.